- Open Access
Optoelectronic system for the determination of blood volume in pneumatic heart assist devices
© Konieczny et al. 2015
- Received: 4 August 2015
- Accepted: 30 November 2015
- Published: 10 December 2015
The following article describes the concept of optical measurement of blood volume in ventricular assist devices (VAD’s) of the pulsatile type. The paper presents the current state of art in blood volume measurements of such devices and introduces a newly developed solution in the optic domain. The objective of the research is to overcome the disadvantages of the previously developed acoustic method—the requirement of additional sensor chamber.
The idea of a compact measurement system has been introduced, followed by laboratory measurements. Static tests of the system have been presented, followed by dynamic measurements on a physical model of the human ventricular system. The results involving the measurements of blood chamber volume acquired by means of an optical system have been compared with the results acquired by means of the Transonic T410 ultrasound flow rate sensor (11PLX transducer, uncertainty ±5 %).
Preliminary dynamic measurements conducted on the physical model of the human cardiovascular system show that the proposed optical measurement system may be used to measure the transient blood chamber volumes of pulsatile VAD’s with the uncertainties (standard mean deviation) lower than 10 %.
The results show that the noninvasive measurements of the temporary blood chamber volume in the POLVAD prosthesis with the use of the developed optical system allows us to carry out accurate static and dynamic measurements.
- Ventricular assist device
- Reflectance measurements
- Transient blood volume
- Cardiac output
- Optoelectronic sensor
Heart problems are nowadays the major cause of death. Most heart and cardiovascular diseases are caused by hypertension, which is usually conditioned by the use of drugs. At the same time, we can observe a growing number of patients with III and IV stage heart failures (NYHA scale) , in which pressor amine drugs alone can be ineffective and a surgery procedure is required. In such cases, the ventricular assist device (VAD) can be used to support the heart muscle in the pumping process of blood. It releases the heart muscle from much effort, thus the life of the patient waiting for a heart transplant can be prolonged, or in some cases can bring about a partial or full recovery of the heart muscle . There are two main types of VAD used in medical applications: pulsatile and non-pulsatile ones . Recent research studies seem to prove that both types of devices can be successfully used in supporting the heart muscle. Non-pulsatile solutions can be smaller in size and easier to implant in a patient’s body as compared with pulsatile solutions. In spite of that, there are still cases in which pulsatile solutions are preferred , especially in the cases when the patient is subjected to conditioning for heart transplantation. The pulsatile solutions are usually paracorporeal, and usually connected with the human ventricular system in parallel with the human heart, thus they can be used in some cases for the recovery of the heart muscle.
Objective of the research
The changes of air pressure inside the pneumatic chamber cause the movement of the membrane, thus pumping the blood. Air pressure changes are induced using the pneumatic driving unit (Fig. 1b). The direction of the blood flow is determined by a relative configuration of the valves in the connectors.
State of art
Cardiac recovery by mechanical heart supporting is a complex process. It occurs in about 20 % of cases involving the mechanical supporting of the heart by means of blood pumps . During the recovery, the cardiac function gradually improves and the total blood flow in the aorta increases . It necessitates a gradual reduction of the mechanical supporting of the heart.
In the current state of art, the POLVAD and ReligaHeart EXT ventricular assist devices, as well as other solutions of such pneumatic assist devices, are not equipped with systems monitoring the actual (transient) blood volume inside the prosthesis. Its semitransparent casing allows the medical staff to evaluate the heart support process visually and by monitoring the patients vitals. This approach requires a continuous medical assistance. Patients need to be hospitalized all the time, which causes a major discomfort and significantly reduces their mobility. The solutions of ultrasound measurements are expensive and large in size. Therefore, their application is mostly limited to clinical conditions.
Polish experience involving the application of the cardiac assist system POLCAS in more than 300 cases proved that the best clinical results were obtained by synchronous supporting [7, 8], commonly with the manual reduction of heart supporting during the recovery. The measurement of the actual blood chamber volume might significantly improve the recovery process by providing feedback information about the cardiac output of the prosthesis. This information about the current state of VAD device would be a milestone in automating the heart support process completely.
Currently, all over the world, the most popular method for estimating the cardiac output of pneumatic VAD is the measurement of flow rate, using the ultrasound flow rate meters . These devices are expensive and fairly large in their size. Although the measurements are accurate, the mobility of the patients is still considerably restricted.
The most important issue in supporting the heart with VAD is to empty completely the device in each cycle, so that the blood might circulate properly in the device. In the case of a partial ejection the volume of blood that remains in the blood chamber has by about 60 % longer contact with the biomaterial than the portion of blood ejected directly from the VAD, which can lead to the formation of thrombus. Moreover, the washing of internal surface of the blood chamber is better in the case of a total ejection than in the case of partial ejection [10, 11]. That is why the determination of the minimum-filling state is of crucial importance.
The existing solutions incorporated in the VAD device and used in patients allow us to determine only the full- and minimum-filling states of the prosthesis, using a simple optical or magnetic switch . This is unfortunately only a partial solution of the problem. In that configuration, the sensor does not allow us to monitor the actual output of the assist device. At some point the air flow measurements in the pneumatic duct were used to measure the pneumatic part volume. The method provided the measurements with the 10–20 % uncertainties . The newer approach to the subject matter was based only on the measurements of pressure . Both methods, however, required frequent calibration cycles, using the reference method. There were many other approaches to solve that problem in the pneumatic type of VAD [15–18]. One of the promising solutions developed in our Department was based on the concept of Helmholtz’s acoustic resonator [17–19]. In that solution, the pneumatic part acts as an acoustic resonator. The elaborated method allows us to determine the actual volume of the prosthesis, but requires an additional sensor chamber over the pneumatic part of the prosthesis. It increases the total volume of the VAD. Although the method was successfully tested in laboratory conditions, it has not been incorporated in the new model of the VAD. To the Authors’ knowledge, there is no solution incorporated in the pneumatic VAD used in patients, allowing to estimate online the blood volume in the VAD device. Another solution developed by the Authors of the manuscript is focused on the application of the ultrasound Doppler method . It was proved that apart from the information about the velocity of the flow, the energy of ultrasound echo contains the information about micro-objects drifting in the blood [21, 22]. This effect offers an opportunity to detect micro-emboli and larger clots, which can be then used in controlling the anticoagulation in order to increase the patient’s safety.
Optical measurement system
The experience gained with the acoustic method was used in the development of a new solution—an optical one. The proposed measurement system must be noninvasive to blood environment. That is why, most of transient blood volume measurement methods are taking advantage of the properties of the membrane, which separates the blood chamber and the pneumatic chamber of the VAD, at the pneumatic part. The proposed measurement system has no contact with blood environment. The blood volume in the blood part of the prosthesis is estimated by the measurement of the volume of the pneumatic part.
The VAD model used in the performed research studies was produced using rapid prototyping techniques. The internal dimensions of the model are the same as in the medically used VADs.
The membrane which is used to separate the blood part from the pneumatic part is exactly the same as that used in actual prosthesis: two layers made of Chronoflex ARLT, separated by the graphite powder for reducing the friction between the two layers.
Preliminary research studies
The preliminary research studies (performed at the Department of Optoelectronics, Silesian University of Technology, Poland) comprised static and low dynamicity testing (<5 ml/s), aiming to determine the behavior of the membrane and the development of the electronics and software for the measurement system [27, 28]. Since the membrane in this construction changes its shape in a random manner during the process of blood pumping, it was decided that in the first stage of the investigations, the optical method would use 12 light emitting diodes and 32 photodiodes. In each measurement cycle, each IR light emitting diode was powered (one at a time), and the signal from all 32 photodiodes was detected. In order to achieve the sufficient speed of acquisition, fast multiple input A/D converters had to be used, along with precise amplifiers connected to each of the photodiodes. Four 8-channel A/D converters were used, interrogated by 2 MHz SPI bus. The proper time delay between the consecutive interrogations introduced by the software, was based on research studies concerning the photodiode circuit response times, after the light emitting diodes had been lit. The time of one cycle for all single light emitting diode–single photodiode configurations (equal to 384) amounted to 100 ms.
Due to the above and because of the significant quantity of data to be processed, it was decided that data-mining techniques should be used.
The PCA (principal components analysis) method was used, mainly because of its nonparametric operation, the possibility to reduce the number of dimensions of the input data, as well as to identify of redundant data . The measurement results were then classified basing on the volume of the blood part, measured using the reference method. The process was repeated for different objective functions, aiming at the best separation of the data points for different blood part volumes. This process resulted in a 3D space, formed by three first principal components, where selected blood part volumes were represented (each 5 ml in a range of 0–80 ml). The process of finding the actual volume required the transformation of the input data into the 3D space of the principal components, and the localization of the nearest volume using k-NN (k Nearest Neighbors) algorithm. The algorithm allowed us to determine unequivocally the volume of the pneumatic part, when three adjacent neighbors were localized.
The analysis resulted in the selection of a set of three light emitting diodes (E1, E8, E10) (marked in Fig. 3b) and some photodiodes, allowing to reduce the required number of configurations (features) to 34. The calculated function allowed us to determine the volume in low dynamic conditions . A more detailed description of this problem can be found in .
The successful preliminary results obtained by means of PCA and k-NN [26, 27] provided a solid basis, allowing to prepare the optical measurement system for dynamic measurements at the Foundation of Cardiac Surgery Development (FRK). The system was modified to acquire measurement results with the required rate. The measuring time of a single cycle was reduced from 100 to 35 ms for all combinations (384 E-PD pairs). Additionally, the configurations of the chosen light emitting diodes and photodiodes were programmed on the basis of the data acquired in the course of the static measurements. It enabled a further increase of the acquisition speed, resulting in 10 ms measurement cycles for the selected combinations.
Preliminary dynamic measurements of the optical measurement system were performed at the FRK. The physical model of the human cardiovascular system was used . The independent volume measurement method consisting of two ultrasound flow rate meters (at the inflow and outflow of the prosthesis) was used as the reference. Transonic T410 (11PLX transducer—5 % uncertainty) flow rate meters were applied in the experiment. The ultrasound sensors used in the measurements were previously calibrated using the Fluxus ultrasound flowmeter (2 % uncertainty).
The blood-like liquid used during the measurements was a 60 % water solution of glycerin mixed with benzoic aldehyde (capillary viscometer measurement result: 8.5 cP at 25 °C).
During the tests, several heart support speeds (average heart rate—AHR) and blood duct impedances were used. This allowed us to analyze various working modes of the prosthesis: full filling/full ejecting, full filling/partial ejecting, partial filling/partial ejecting and partial filling/full ejecting.
Dynamic measurements were realized under various driving pressures and various blood duct impedances at the inflow and outflow cannulas, which allowed us to modify the filling and ejecting process of the prosthesis under similar driving pressures.
The complete set of optical measurements and the ultrasound measurements of the derived flow rate data was analyzed by means of the numerical methods (PCA and k-NN).
The PCA was used to select the light emitting diode–photodiode configurations that could provide an unequivocal relation between the amplitude on the detectors and the volume of the blood part.
During the dynamic tests, realized on the model of human cardiovascular system, the elaborated system acquired data from all 384 configurations. Additionally, the reduced number of configurations (34 features preselected by the PCA) was used in a faster acquisition program.
Due to the requirement of limited changes in the construction of the prosthesis, inflicted by the manufactures of the cardiac support system, in order to maintain the integrity of the construction of the prosthesis casing, it was decided that the number of sensor elements should be limited. Basing on the manufacturers’ suggestions, in order not to hinder the mechanical properties of the casing of the prosthesis, it was agreed that the maximum number of light emitting diode and photodiode elements incorporated into the casing of the prosthesis should not exceed eight.
The Authors were able to select three configurations out of 34 preselected previously using the PCA, that provided the possibility to determine an unequivocal transfer function.
The combinations that were used in the final solution are: E1-PD1, E1-PD32, E8-PD15 (Fig. 6a).
Basing on the amplitude of the signal on the photodiode for the particular configurations, it is possible to determine the volume of the blood part. The configuration E8-PD15 is used to determine the lower volumes (<35 ml); E1-PD1 is used for the range 35–75 ml. The E1-PD32 configuration is used to detect the equivocal part of the E1-PD1 configuration at higher volumes (>75 ml) (Fig. 6b).
Knowing the required number of configurations, the size of the measurement system was reduced; the electronic circuit was redesigned to a more compact one. In order to reduce the size of the electronic circuit, a 4-layer transducer board was used. In Fig. 7a the reduced preliminary system is shown. Finally, the optical system was reduced to two light emitting diodes (E1, E8) and three photodiodes (PD1, PD15, PD32) marked in Fig. 6a.
Figure 8 presents the volume calculated with the use of flow rate measurements and the volume results from the optical system.
We can observe in Fig. 8a–c that the blood volume measurements obtained by means of the new optic method coincide with the results calculated with the use of flow rate measurements. The exemplary results show three different test series: 8a—operating with AHR = 30, at approximately half of the maximum stroke volume of the VAD; 8b—operating with the same AHR and pneumatic driving pressures, but with slightly reduced blood duct impedances resulting in larger stroke volume of the VAD; 8c—VAD operating at AHR = 50 bpm with full stroke volume). The measurements of mid-range (30–40 ml) volumes showed the artefacts marked in Fig. 8b. They can be related to the rapid change in the shape of the membrane (from convex to concave character in relation to the pneumatic part casing) and ought to be improved. When the impedances of the blood duct change, which takes place in the case of the human cardiovascular system, the same driving pressures of the VAD result in a different stroke volume (Fig. 8a, b). By comparing the driving pressures with the volumes of the blood part acquired using the proposed method, it would be possible to detect the changes in the impedance of the blood duct, providing important information concerning the state of the supported cardiovascular system.
In Fig. 8d, we compared the average SV (stroke volume) results obtained in the optic system with average SV results obtained using the flow rate measurements at five experiments under different heart support conditions. The stroke volume measurements can be used for the estimation of the CO (cardiac output) of the VAD, which is a well-recognized parameter in heart support processes.
The redesigned solution will be a subject of extended tests in the presence of clinically applied ultrasound flow rate sensors as a reference method of measuring the volume.
The paper presents the results of investigation studies involving dynamic blood chamber volume measurements of the pulsatile, pneumatic type heart support device. The research studies are focused on the development of an optical measurement system. The dynamic measurements were performed on the model of the human cardiovascular system at the Foundation of Cardiac Surgery Development in Zabrze, Poland . Ultrasound flow rate sensors were used as a reference volume measurement method. The method was tested in changing operating conditions of the VAD device with various driving pressures of the heart assist device, various impedances in the blood duct, varying heart rates.
The results of the performed measurements, making use of the optical system and the reference method, show that the proposed optical method can be applied for accurate blood chamber volume measurements. A direct comparison of the average blood output volume during consecutive cycles using both methods confirms the above declaration.
Future research studies will comprise the examination of a miniaturized measurement system as well as an improvement of the measurement algorithm. The optical measurement system meets all requirements for a noninvasive transient blood volume measurement system.
The proposed method is designed for pulsatile type VADs, which are usually extracorporeal solutions. In that case, the device will be directly powered. The elaborated system at the current state of development requires approximately 100 mW of electric power. Further investigations aiming at miniaturizing the measurement system should provide an additional essential reduction of power consumption, which would be important if used in the future in intracorporeal pulsatile VADs, or battery powered solutions.
According to an extended search in literature and the Authors’ knowledge, the proposed measurement method (and the elaborated system) is an original and novel solution of blood chamber volume measurements in pneumatic heart assist devices. The optical solution has been submitted to be patented .
The optical method of blood volume measurement presented in the paper may be used as a method to assess the location of the membrane (e.g. to detect the full filling and full ejection of blood from the blood chamber). In conjunction with an ultrasound Doppler assessment of micro-emboli it may constitute an automated extracorporeal cardiac assist system.
GK participated in all of researches and development of the measurement method, carried out the data analysis and drafted the manuscript. TP participated in the design and coordination of the study and revised the manuscript. MS participated in all of researches and development of the miniaturized measurement circuit and carried out data analysis. MG participated in the dynamic measurements on the measurement stand at the Foundation of Cardiac Surgery Development and participated in data analysis. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The work is partially financed by the Silesian University of Technology, Faculty of Electrical Engineering within the BKM/514/RE4/2014 and BKM/534/RE4/2015 and The National Centre of Research and Development (Warsaw, Poland), within the grant No. PBS1/A3/11/2012.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
- Schartel SA, Pai SS. Mechanical hemodynamic support. In: Criner GJ, Barnette RE, D’Alonzo GE, editors. Critical care study guide, vol XXII. 2nd ed. New York: Springer; 2010. p. 918–49.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Young JB. Healing the heart with ventricular assist device therapy: mechanisms of cardiac recovery. Ann Thorac Surg. 2001;71:S210–9.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ravishankar C, Dominguez TE, Rosenthal TM, Gaynor JW. Mechanical circulatory support in the patient with congenital heart disease. In: Shaddy RE, editor. Heart failure in congenital heart disease: from fetus to adult, 1st ed. London: Springer; 2010. p. 123–54.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Pacholewicz J, Zakliczyński M, Barańska-Kosakowska A, Religa G, Siondalski P, Kucewicz E, Nadziakiewicz P, Zembala M. Efficacy of treatment with pulsatile pump as a bridge to transplantation in patients with a congestive heart failure—polish experiences with POLVAD. J Heart Lung Transpl. 2009;28:S98.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Maybaum S, Mancini D, Xydas S, et al. Cardiac improvement during mechanical circulatory support a prospective multicenter study of the Lvad Working Group. Circulation. 2007;115:2497–505.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gawlikowski M, Pustelny T, Kustosz R. The physical parameters estimation of physiologically worked heart prosthesis. J PHYS-PARIS IV. 2006;137:73–8.Google Scholar
- Pacholewicz J, Zakliczyński M, Kowalik V, Kalarus Z, Zembala M. Bridge to recovery in two cases of dilated cardiomyopathy after long-term mechanical circulatory support. Kardiochir I Torakochir Polska. 2014;11(2):69–172.Google Scholar
- Pacholewicz J, Hrapkowicz T, Chodor B, Zembala M, Religa Z. Good long-term result of biventricular assisted circulation using Polcas-Religa system in 16-year old boy with a irreversible heart failure—a case report. Kardiochir I Torakochir Polska. 2009;6(4):377–83.Google Scholar
- Slaughter MS, Bartoli CR, Sobieski MA, Pantalos GM. Intraoperative evaluation of the HeartMate II Flow estimator. J Heart Lung Transpl. 2009;28(1):39–43.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Deutsch S, Tarbell J, Manning K, Rosenberg G, Fontaine A. Experimental fluid mechanics of pulsatile artificial blood pumps. Annu Rev Fluid Mech. 2006;8:65–86.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wootton D, Ku D. Fluid mechanics of vascular systems, diseases, and thrombosis. Annu Rev Biomed Eng. 1999;1:299–329.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Reichenbach SH, Farrar DJ, Hill JD. A Versatile intracorporeal ventricular assist device based on the thoratec VAD system. Ann Thorac Surg. 2001;71:171–5.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Shaw WJ, Pantalos GM, Everett S, Olsen DB. Factors influencing the accuracy of the cardiac output monitoring and diagnostic unit for pneumatic artificial hearts. ASAIO Trans. 1990;36(3):M264–8.Google Scholar
- Nishinaka T, Taenaka Y, Tatsumi E, Ohnishi H, et al. Development of a compact portable driver for a pneumatic ventricular assist device. J Artif Organs. 2007;10(4):236–9.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Komorowski D, Gawlikowski M. Preliminary investigations regarding the blood volume estimation in pneumatically controlled ventricular assist device by pattern recognition. Comput Recogn Syst 2 Adv Soft Comput. 2007;45:558–65.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sobotnicki A, Pałko T, Mocha J, Czerw M. Evaluation of volumetric parameters of the ventricular assist device using bioimpedance method. J Med Inform Technol. 2012;19:117–23.Google Scholar
- Opilski Z, Konieczny G, Pustelny T, Gacek A, Kustosz R. Noninvasive acoustic blood volume measurement system for the POLVAD prosthesis. Bull Pol Acad Sci Tech Sci. 2011;59(4):429–33.Google Scholar
- Konieczny G, Opilski Z, Pustelny T, Gawlikowski M. Acoustic system for the estimation of the temporary blood chamber volume of the POLVAD heart supporting prosthesis. Biomed Eng Online. 2012;11:72. doi:10.1186/1475-925X-11-72.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Konieczny G, Pustelny T, Opiski Z, Gawlikowski M. Acoustic system of determining the instantaneous volume of the blood part of the ventricular assist device POLVAD-EXT. Arch Acoust. 2014;39(4):541–8.Google Scholar
- Gawlikowski M, Lewandowski M, Nowicki A, et al. The application of ultrasonic methods to flow measurement and detection of microembolus in heart prostheses. Acta Phys Polonica A. 2013;124(3):417–20.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Palanchon P, Boukaz A, Klein J, De Jong N. Subharmonic and ultraharmonic emissions for emboli detection and characterization. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2003;29(3):417–25.Google Scholar
- Cowe J, Gittins J, Naylor AR, Evans DH. RF signals provide additional information on embolic events recorded during TCD monitoring. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2005;31(5):613–23.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Missoffe A, Chassagne L, Topçu S, et al. New simple optical sensor: from nanometer resolution to centimeter displacement range. Sensor Actuator A Phys. 2012;176:46–52.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Fleming AJ. A review of nanometer resolution position sensors: operation and performance. Sensor Actuator A-Phys. 2013;190:106–26.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Konieczny G, Pustelny T, Marczyński P. Optical sensor for measurements of the blood chamber volume in the POLVAD prosthesis—static measurements. Acta Phys Pol A. 2013;124(3):479–82.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Konieczny G, Pustelny T, Marczyński P. Quasi-dynamic testing of an optical sensor for measurements of the blood chamber volume in the POLVAD prosthesis. Acta Phys Pol, A. 2013;124(3):483–5.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Marczynski P, Konieczny G, Pustelny T. Research on pattern recognition applied for volume estimation of blood chamber with matrix of optical sensors. Acta Phys Pol A. 2013;124(3):498–501.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ferrari G, Kozarski M, De Lazzari C, et al. Development of a hybrid (numerical-hydraulic) circulatory model: prototype testing and its response to IABP assistance. Int J Artif Organs. 2005;28(7):750–9.Google Scholar
- Pustelny T, Konieczny G. Method for measuring instantenous blood volume in cardiac support chamber. Pol Pat Off Off Gaz. 1055;13(2014):9.Google Scholar