- Open Access
Emphysema early diagnosis using X-ray diffraction enhanced imaging at synchrotron light source
BioMedical Engineering OnLine volume 13, Article number: 82 (2014)
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is one of the leading causes of morbidity and mortality worldwide, and emphysema is a common component of COPD. Currently, it is very difficult to detect early stage emphysema using conventional radiographic imaging without contrast agents, because the change in X-ray attenuation is not detectable with absorption-based radiography. Compared with the absorption-based CT, phase contrast imaging has more advantages in soft tissue imaging, because of its high spatial resolution and contrast.
In this article, we used diffraction enhanced imaging (DEI) method to get the images of early stage emphysematous and healthy samples, then extract X-ray absorption, refraction, and ultra-small-angle X-ray scattering (USAXS) information from DEI images using multiple image radiography (MIR). We combined the absorption image with the USAXS image by a scatter plot. The critical threshold in the scatter plot was calibrated using the linear discriminant function in the pattern recognition.
USAXS image was sensitive to the change of tissue micro-structure, it could show the lesions which were invisible in the absorption image. Combined with the absorption-based image, the USAXS information enabled better discrimination between healthy and emphysematous lung tissue in a mouse model. The false-color images demonstrated that our method was capable of classifying healthy and emphysematous tissues.
Here we present USAXS images of early stage emphysematous and healthy samples, where the dependence of the USAXS signal on micro-structures of biomedical samples leads to improved diagnosis of emphysema in lung radiographs.
X-ray technology is widely used in medicine, biological and material research since Roentgen discovered X-ray in 1895. Now, imaging techniques used in clinical diagnosis mainly include X-ray fluoroscopy, X-ray photography and computed tomography (CT) imaging, etc., they derive contrast from difference in X-ray absorption. However, the differences in X-ray absorption coefficients of the structure in biological soft tissues are quite small, thus the contrast and spatial resolution of these techniques are quite low. When lesions were found by X-ray absorption-based radiography, the patient has missed the best period of treatment [1–3]. In the diagnosis of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) also confronted with this problem.
COPD is one of the leading causes of morbidity and mortality worldwide , it is presumed that the mortality of COPD will rise to the third place in the world . Emphysema is a common component of COPD, it is characterized by airflow limitation and excessive inflation which enlarge distal airspace and decrease the elasticity of pulmonary alveoli . Chest X-ray is the conventional imaging methods for detection of emphysema. Due to changes in the lung tissue density of mild to moderate emphysema are quite small, the image of chest X-ray may be completely normal. In a study by Klein et al. , the sensitivity of chest radiography in the diagnosis of emphysema was 34%. Currently, early diagnosis of COPD and emphysema largely relies on spirometric lung function tests. However, because of the strong compensatory ability of lung, spirometric lung function tests may not be sensitive enough for measuring alterations in lung function at the early stages of emphysema . A research  showed that the sensitivity of the spirometry in early diagnosis of the emphysema was about 80%. Histological examination is the most commonly method to observe micro-structure of biological tissues, it can observe the pathological change of early stage emphysema, but this method is invasive and not repeatable [9, 10]. In our research, we identified mild emphysema successfully, and located lesion regions with false-color.
Lung is a kind of gas-bearing spongy tissue, compared with the phase contrast imaging, there is still a limit on the spatial resolution and contrast with the absorption-based CT . In recent years, many studies have shown that X-ray phase contrast imaging of synchrotron radiation source can be used to observe the structure of the lung sample on the order of microns and conduce to lung disease diagnosis [11–13]. Now, the main phase contrast imaging methods include interferometry, diffraction enhanced imaging, in-line phase contrast X-ray imaging and grating-based X-ray imaging. Since Chapman proposed the diffraction enhanced imaging (DEI) method and put forward the calculation formulation of absorption image and refraction image, DEI has been widely used in various research fields. The DEI technique utilizes the analyzer crystal with an acceptance angle range of only a few micro-radians. The high angular sensitivity of the crystal allows the X-ray absorption, refraction, and ultra-small-angle X-ray scatter (USAXS) of the sample to be measured. The DEI information extraction [14, 15] provided a way to present the absorption, refraction, and USAXS information individually. Those images possess higher contrast, and they can provide more detailed information of the sample.
Materials and methods
The principle of DEI
The DEI setup is sketched in Figure 1, it is composed of two perfect crystals’ monochromator-analyzer system with a sample placed between them. The monochromator is used to generate a nearly monochromatic X-ray beam, the beam transmitted through the sample is incident upon the analyzer crystal, and the intensity of the X-ray beam reflected by the analyzer crystal is measured by a detector, which results in the formation of a DEI image . When the X-ray beam transmits through a sample, the interactions between the X-ray and the sample include absorption, refraction, USAXS, and so on. When monochromatic crystal is fixed, and the analyzer crystal rotate in the meridian plan, we use the rocking curve to describe the reflectivity of the analyzer crystal as a function of the angle of analyzer crystal, as shown in Figure 2. According to Bragg’s diffraction law (2d * sin(θ ± Δθ) = n * (λ ± Δλ)), only the X-ray satisfying the Bragg condition of the analyzer crystal will be reflected onto the detector.
Randomly selected six-wk-old Balb/c mice were used throughout this study. Mice had free access to water and rodent laboratory chow. The mice were anesthetized and applied papain through endotracheal instillation once a week (6 U/kg body weight), which continued four weeks. Then the animals were humanely sacrificed after ten days. The lung sample was prepared following the instillation-based inflation-fixation method established by Heitzman [17, 18]. All experiments and procedures carried out on the animals were approved by Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee of Capital Medical University and the approved ID is AEEI-2014-049.
Diffraction enhanced X-ray imaging
The experiments were conducted at the 4W1A beamline of Beijing Synchrotron Radiation Facility (BSRF). Two perfect crystals Si (111) were used as the monochromator and analyzer. The X-ray beam energy was set at 15Kev during the experiments. The detector had an VHR-16 M high resolution X-ray Imaging Camera system (Photonic Science Ltd.) with 4872*3248 pixels, and 7.4*7.4 μm2 per pixel, with a field of view of 36*24 mm2. Two series of DEI images were acquired in 23 positions of the RC, one with the sample and one without the sample, and they could be used to obtain absorption, refraction, and USAXS images. The samples were placed in a plastic container when acquire the DEI images.
In the study of information extraction method, Chapman et al.  presented the original information extraction method and produced images known as the apparent absorption image and refraction image using two images taken on either side of the RC of the analyzing crystal, in 1997. This method is simple to calculate, but the images acquired through this method are influenced by scattering, which reduces the spatial resolution . Wernick et al.  proposed multiple image radiography (MIR) based on a statistical analysis. It can produce true absorption, refraction and USAXS images, respectively, and it is more robust to noise . However, MIR increases the imaging time and X-ray radiation dose of the sample due to the need for more DEI images.
C.Hu et al.  made further explainations about MIR based on Wernick et al. . In MIR, two series of DEI images are acquired in N (N>2) positions of the RC, one with the sample and one without the sample. In the following formulas , Iabs, Δθ, denotes the absorption, refraction and USAXS information, respectively, Is(θn) (n =1,2,…,N ) denotes the intensity of the DEI image in the position θn of the RC with the sample. Ib(θn) (n=1,2,…,N) denotes the intensity of the DEI image in the position θn of the RC without the sample. The MIR absorption image is similar to a conventional radiograph, but exhibits greater contrast owing to the scattering rejection.
Multiple projections of three emphysematous and three healthy mouse lung samples were acquired at the 4W1A beamline of Beijing Synchrotron Radiation Facility (BSRF). Then calculated the absorption, refraction and USAXS images using MIR. Figure 3(A), (B), (C), (D), (E), (F) show absorption, refraction and USAXS images of the healthy and emphysematous sample, respectively. Compared with the images of healthy mouse lung sample, the mean pixel value of emphysematous one is higher in absorption image but lower in USAXS image. The image texture of refraction image in emphysema lung is more irregular than it in the image of healthy sample. In a comparison of the absorption image, the USAXS image can be more clear to show the diseased region, as shown in the red circle in Figure 3.The change in alveoli diameter is well represented in the histological sections of healthy (Figure 4A and C) and emphysematous lung samples (Figure 4B and D), where a significant increase in mean alveolar diameter accompanied by the loss in lung tissue is apparent in the 10-fold magnification of emphysematous mouse lung tissue (Figure 4D).In order to get a better diagnosis of emphysema, we combined the absorption image with the USAXS image by a scatter plot. Figure 5 displayed the comparison results of each healthy and emphysematous lung sample by scatter plots respectively. The apparent discrimination of healthy and emphysematous lung tissues in the scatter plot can be visualized in the calculated projection images by linear discriminant function to select the pixels of emphysematous that show a large deviation from the healthy (blue) straight line. Compared to the deviation of the absorption images (X-axis) of the two groups, the deviation of the USAXS images (Y-axis) is more obvious, as shown in Figure 5. In other words, the USAXS image is more sensitive to diagnose the emphysema or even other pulmonary diseases. Figure 6 are the scatter plot in three-dimensional, the Z-axis presents the number of the pixels at the XY plane's each position, the blue presents the healthy sample and the color presents the emphysematous sample. The discrimination between the peaks of two kinds of samples is apparent, this indicates that the three-dimensional plot can provide more evidences for qualitative diagnosis.The main appearance of early stage emphysema is alveolar inflation, which changes the spatial frequency of tissue micro-structure. USAXS image is sensitive to the change of tissue micro-structure, it can show the lesions which are invisible in the absorption image. In scatter plots, lower pixel value means more serious alveolar inflation. According to those scatter plots, we compared all the emphysematous samples with each healthy sample to distinguish the disease level, as shown in Figure 7. The results displayed the changes of the micro-structure of the lung tissues in jet colors based on the boundary produced by linear discriminant analysis, where high values (yellow, red) correspond to lower scattering from the sample at comparable absorption properties, thus revealing larger mean alveoli diameter. The classification results in Figure 7 showed that the diseased regions of the same emphysematous lung sample had the same varying tendency under different healthy samples, which indicated the method we proposed is feasible.
Because of the low spatial resolution, CT results are limited mainly to structural analyses of larger airways. The change in X-ray attenuation caused by the pathological process of pulmonary emphysema is difficult to detect in early stage of the disease using conventional absorption-based radiography without contrast agents. Xenon ventilation CT using dual source and dual energy is a new technique for functional lung imaging which visualises lung ventilation and allows quantification of regional ventilation defects as well as gas trapping behind obstructed airways . It can be used as a novel parameter to assess the severity of emphysema, but the defect is xenon may cause serious complication such as respiratory depression.
MR imaging of the lung is difficult because of its weak MR signal. Hyperpolarised helium-3 or xenon-129 are a new class of MR contrast agents ,they can be used to obtain high spatial resolution images of the lung airspaces. However, current capability to generate hyperpolarised gas for MR imaging is predominantly restricted to specialised centres in Europe and North America .
Currently, early diagnosis of COPD and emphysema largely relies on spirometric lung function tests. However, the tests are not so sensitive to the early stage emphysema. Compared with it, because of the high spatial resolution and no contrast agents, the DEI technique has more advantages in early emphysema diagnosis.
The scanning time in our experiments is a little longer than the time used in a conventional clinical chest radiograph, so a reduction of the number of scan steps is needed. It is observed that the rocking curve near the waist position can be similar to a straight line, where we can increase the scan interval angle and calculate the missing images using linear interpolation to reduce the scanning time and radiation dose.
The small airways due to the specific anatomical and pathophysiological features do not usually cause clinical symptoms if the disease does not affect larger airways . It seems that small airways and alveoli are the main point of airflow limitation and the attack occurs from the early stage in patients with COPD. Therefore, the role of the small airways and alveoli in the pathophysiology of obstructive lung diseases is important. However, no one method can currently be considered as a “gold standard” to assess the function of small airways.
In this paper, we utilized the MIR to extracted the absorption, refraction and USAXS images of the healthy and early stage emphysematous lung samples. A combination of absorption and USAXS information in a scatter-plot analysis presents improved emphysema diagnosis of mice lungs. We found that the strong dependence of USAXS information on the changes of micro-structure in lung tissue, especially in small airways and alveoli, plays an important role in early diagnosis of pulmonary emphysema.
In this study, the isolated mice lung samples were used in the experiments. In the future, with the development of technology and improvement of experimental equipments, research of human lung or other biological tissues in vivo will be conducted. Therefore, the early diagnosis based on the combination of multi-character of the DEI images will have extensive application prospects.
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Diffraction enhanced imaging
Ultra-small-angle X-ray scattering
Multiple image radiography
Beijing synchrotron radiation facility
Hoffman PC, Mauer AM, Vokes EE: Lung cancer. Lancet 2000, 355: 479–485.
Sen S, Reddy VG, Khanna N, Guleria R, Kapila K, Singh N: A comparative study of telomerase activity in sputum, bronchial washing and biopsy specimens of lung cancer. Lung Cancer 2001, 33: 41–49.
Sera T, Uesugi K, Yagi N, Umetani K, Kobatake M, Imai S: High-resolution visualization of tumours in rabbit lung using refraction contrast X-ray imaging. Eur J Radiol 2008, 68: 54–57.
Schleede S, Meinel FG, Bech M, Herzen J, Achterhold K, Potdevin G, Malecki A, Adam-Neumair S, Thieme SF, Bamberg F, Nikolaou K, Bohla A, Yildirim AÖ, Roderick L, Martin G, Ronald R, Oliver E, Maximilian R, Franz P: Emphysema diagnosis using X-ray dark- field imaging at a laser-driven compact synchrotron light source. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2012, 109: 17880–17885.
Van Tho N, Wada H, Ogawa E, Nakano Y: Recent findings in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease by using quantitative computed tomography. Res Inves 2012, 50: 78–87.
Klein JS, Gamsu G, Webb RW, Golden JA, Muller NL: HRCT diagnosis of emphysema in a symptomatic patients with normal chest radiographs and isolated low diffusion capacity. Radiology 1992, 182: 817–821.
Anne-Helene J, Amir S, Anna-Maria Dutius A, Catharina Z, Fehniger TE, Stevens TR, Xiangdong W: Evaluation of excised lung gas volume measurements in animals with genetic or induced emphysema. Respir Physiol Neurobiol 2006, 150: 240–250.
Mostafa MMS: Role of the chest radiography, spirometry, and high resolution computed tomography in the early diagnosis of the emphysema. Egyptian J Radiol Nuc Med 2010, 41: 509–515.
Burdett CL, Critchley RJ, Black F, Barnard S, Clark SC, Corris PA, Gould KF, Butt T, Dark JH: Invasive biopsy is effective and useful after lung transplant. J Heart Lung Transplant 2010, 29: 759–763.
Horst Detlef L, Christoph N, Alexander M, Susanne G, Andreas B, Folker Ernst F, Wolfgang K, Wigbert Stephan R: Three-dimensional imaging and morphometric analysis of alveolar tissue from microfocal X-ray-computed tomography. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 2006, 291: 535–545.
Parsons DW, Morgan K, Donnelley M, Fouras A, Crosbie J, Williams I, Boucher RC, Uesugi K, Naoto Y, Karen KW S: High-resolution visualization of airspace structures in intact mice via synchrotron phase-contrast X-ray imaging (PCXI). J Anat 2008, 213: 217–227.
Zhang L, Li D, Luo S: Non-Invasive Microstructure and Morphology Investigation of the Mouse Lung: Qualitative Description and Quantitative Measurement. PLoS One 2011,6(2):e17400.
Hwang J, Kim M, Kim S, Jinwon L: Quantifying Morphological Parameters of the Terminal Branching Units in a Mouse Lung by Phase Contrast Synchrotron Radiation Computed Tomography. PLoS One 2013,8(5):e63552.
Oltulu O, Zhong Z, Hasnah M, Wernick MN, Dean C: Extraction of extinction, refraction and absorption properties in diffraction enhanced imaging. J Phys D Appl Phys 2003, 36: 2152–2156.
Chunhong H, Tao Z, Lu Z, Hui L, Xinyan Z, Shuqian L: Information extraction and CT reconstruction of liver images based on diffraction enhanced imaging. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2009, 19: 955–962.
Chapman D, Thomlinson W, Johnston RE, Washburn D, Pisano E, Gmur N, Zhong Z, Menk R, Arfelli F, Sayers D: Diffraction enhanced X-ray imaging. Phys Med Biol 1997, 42: 2015–2025.
Heitzman ER: The lung: radiologic-pathologic correlations. St. Louis: Mosby; 1984:4–12.
Churg AM, Myers JL, Tazelaar HD, Wright JL: Thurlbeck’s pathology of the lung. New York: Thieme Medical Publishers; 2005:115.
Zhu PP, Yuan QX, Huang WX, Wang Y, Shu H, Wu ZY, Xian DC: The principle of diffraction enhanced imaging. Acta Physics Sinica 2006, 55: 1089–1097. (in Chinese) [朱佩平,袁清习,黄万霞,王越,舒航,吴自玉,冼鼎昌,衍射增强成像原理, 物理学报2006,55:1089–1097]
Wernick MN, Oliver W, Dean C, Zhong Z, Galatsanos NP, Yongyi Y, Brankov JG, Oral O, Anastasio MA, Carol M: Multiple-image radiography. Phys Med Biol 2003, 48: 3875–3895.
Konstantinos Katsoulis K, Konstantinos K, Theodore K: Techniques for assessing small airways function: Possible applications in asthma and COPD. Respir Med 2013, xx: 1–10.
Thien F: Measuring and imaging small airways dysfunction in asthma. Asia Pacific Allergy 2013, 3: 224–230.
We would like to thank Prof. Zhu Peiping, Dr. Qingxi Yuan, Dr. Wanxia Huang and Dr. Junyue Wang from BSRF for their assistance in our experiments, and thank to Zheng Wang (Cancer Institute & Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences) for providing the healthy and emphysematous mice samples.
This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China, Grant No. 61227802, 60532090 and 30770593, and by the 7th Framework Program of the European Community, Grant Agreement Number PIRSES-GA-2009-269124.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
LD contributed to the formulation of the idea, performed experiments and drafted the manuscript, JL contributed to the conduction of experiments and participated in the development of the methods. WJ contributed to the conduction of experiments. LZ contributed to the conduction of experiments and reviewed the manuscript. MW contributed to the conduction of experiments. HS participated in the development of the method and reviewed the manuscript. SL is the Primary Investigator of the study under which this work was performed and participated in its design and reviewed the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Dong, L., Li, J., Jian, W. et al. Emphysema early diagnosis using X-ray diffraction enhanced imaging at synchrotron light source. BioMed Eng OnLine 13, 82 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1186/1475-925X-13-82
- Pulmonary emphysema
- Diffraction enhanced imaging
- Multiple image radiography
- Early diagnosis