Human coronary plaque wall thickness correlated positively with flow shear stress and negatively with plaque wall stress: an IVUS-based fluid-structure interaction multi-patient study
BioMedical Engineering OnLine volume 13, Article number: 32 (2014)
Atherosclerotic plaque progression and rupture are believed to be associated with mechanical stress conditions. In this paper, patient-specific in vivo intravascular ultrasound (IVUS) coronary plaque image data were used to construct computational models with fluid-structure interaction (FSI) and cyclic bending to investigate correlations between plaque wall thickness and both flow shear stress and plaque wall stress conditions.
IVUS data were acquired from 10 patients after voluntary informed consent. The X-ray angiogram was obtained prior to the pullback of the IVUS catheter to determine the location of the coronary artery stenosis, vessel curvature and cardiac motion. Cyclic bending was specified in the model representing the effect by heart contraction. 3D anisotropic FSI models were constructed and solved to obtain flow shear stress (FSS) and plaque wall stress (PWS) values. FSS and PWS values were obtained for statistical analysis. Correlations with p < 0.05 were deemed significant.
Nine out of the 10 patients showed positive correlation between wall thickness and flow shear stress. The mean Pearson correlation r-value was 0.278 ± 0.181. Similarly, 9 out of the 10 patients showed negative correlation between wall thickness and plaque wall stress. The mean Pearson correlation r-value was -0.530 ± 0.210.
Our results showed that plaque vessel wall thickness correlated positively with FSS and negatively with PWS. The patient-specific IVUS-based modeling approach has the potential to be used to investigate and identify possible mechanisms governing plaque progression and rupture and assist in diagnosis and intervention procedures. This represents a new direction of research. Further investigations using more patient follow-up data are warranted.
Assessing atherosclerotic plaque vulnerability based on limited in vivo patient data has been a major challenge in cardiovascular research and clinical practice [1–7]. Considerable advances in medical imaging technology have been made in recent years to identify vulnerable atherosclerotic plaques in vivo with information about plaque components including lipid-rich necrotic pools, plaque cap, calcification, intraplaque hemorrhage, loose matrix, thrombosis, and ulcers, subject to resolution limitations of current technology. Atherosclerotic plaque progression and rupture are believed to be associated with mechanical stress conditions [6–18]. Parallel to histology-based atherosclerotic plaque classifications introduced by American Heart Association (AHA) [19–21], based on in vivo image data and computational modeling, we have introduced morphology- and stress-based plaque vulnerability indices which provide quantitative plaque assessment (Table 1 and Figure 1) . Knowledge of those associations may be helpful for a better understanding of plaque progression and rupture process and for diagnosis and prevention of atherosclerosis-related cardiovascular diseases.
In vivo image-based coronary plaque modeling papers are relatively rare because clinical recognition of vulnerable coronary plaques has remained challenging [9, 10, 23]. We have published results based on follow-up studies showing that advanced carotid plaque had positive correlation with flow shear stress and negative correlation with plaque wall stress (PWS) . In this paper, patient-specific intravascular ultrasound (IVUS)-based coronary plaque models with fluid-structure interaction (FSI), on-site pressure and ex vivo biaxial mechanical testing of human coronary plaque material properties were constructed to obtain flow shear stress and plaque wall stress data from ten (10) patients to investigate possible associations between vessel wall thickness and both flow shear stress and plaque wall stress conditions. The information may be helpful in establishing mechanisms governing plaque progression and rupture and may eventually be useful in cardiovascular disease diagnosis, prevention, or necessary interventions.
IVUS data acquisition
3D IVUS data were acquired during cardiac catheterization from 10 patients (7 M, 3 F, age: 48-75; median: 55) at Washington University at St. Louis (n = 6) and Cardiovascular Research Foundation (n = 4) after voluntary informed consent, using procedures described in Tang et al. . In this paper, “plaque” was used to indicate the coronary vessel segment chosen for model construction and analysis. Plaque contour detection was performed using automated Virtual Histology software (ver. 3.1) on a Volcano s5 Imaging System (Volcano Corp., Rancho Cordova, CA). On-site blood pressure and flow velocity data were acquired using a Combo-Wire XT 9500 (Volcano Therapeutics, Inc.) 0.014-inch guide-wire with a Doppler flow velocity sensor. The X-ray angiogram (Allura Xper FD10 System, Philips, Bothel, WA) was obtained prior to the pullback of the IVUS catheter to determine the location of the coronary artery stenosis, vessel curvature and its cyclic bending caused by heart contraction. Figure 2 gives plots of a sample plaque IVUS slices, segmented contours, enlarged view, and the reconstructed 3D geometry showing lipid cores. The X-Ray angiogram and vessel bending were shown by Figure 3. Figure 4 shows an on-site pressure and flow velocity measurement screen shot and pressure condition digitized from the IVUS data.
Biaxial testing and anisotropic model of human coronary material properties
A total of eight coronary arteries from 4 cadavers (age range: 50-81) were obtained from the National Disease Research Interchange, PA and from Washington University, St. Louis with proper consent. A custom planar biaxial test device was used under stress control to obtain stress and strain measurements over a wide range of ratios of stress along the longitudinal and circumferential axes of arterial specimen splayed open to form square samples (see Figure 5) . The forces along the axes were measured via two torque transducers via rigid arms (effective resolution ~0.02 N) to determine the stress. Four graphite particles attached to the sample were tracked by a CCD camera to determine 2D strain (640 × 480 pixels; effective resolution ~0.07% strain). The applied maximum longitudinal: circumferential stress ratios were 1:1, 0.7:1, 0.5:1, 1:0.7 and 1:0.5. Based on average stress in the vessel walls at systolic pressure, the maximum engineering stress applied was 250 kPa. The vessel material was assumed to be hyperelastic, anisotropic, nearly-incompressible and homogeneous. A modified Mooney-Rivlin model was used to fit the biaxial data [23, 24]:
where I1 and I2 are the first and second invariants of right Cauchy-Green deformation tensor C defined as C = [C ij ] = XT X, X = [Xij] = [∂xi/∂aj], (xi) is current position, (ai) is original position, I 4 = C ij (n c ) i (n c ) j , n c is the unit vector in the circumferential direction of the vessel, c1, D1, D2, and K1 and K2 are material constants. A least-squares method was used to determine the parameter values in Eq. (1) to fit our experimental circumferential and axial stress-stretch data . Five human coronary plaque samples were tested and the one with median stiffness was used in this paper. The parameter values are: c1 = -1312.9 kPa, c2 = 114.7 kPa, D1 = 629.7 kPa, D2 = 2.0, K1 = 35.9 kPa, K2 = 23.5. Figure 5c shows that our model with parameters selected with this procedure fits very well with the measured experimental data. Our measurements are also consistent with data available in the literature [25–27].
Reconstruction of plaque 3D geometry and mesh generation
All segmented 2D slices were read into ADINA input file. 3D plaque geometry was re-constructed following the procedure described in Yang et al. . Because plaques have complex irregular geometries with component inclusions which are challenging for mesh generation, a component-fitting mesh generation technique was developed to generate mesh for our models . Using this technique, the 3D plaque domain was divided into hundreds of small “volumes” to curve-fit the irregular plaque geometry with plaque component inclusions. The element type used for structural models (vessel and plaque components) was 3D solid 8-node element. The element type used for the fluid model was 3D fluid 4-node elements, free formed mesh. Mesh analysis was performed by decreasing mesh size by 10% (in each dimension) until solution differences (measured by L2 norms of solution differences of all components, including stress, strain, displacements, flow velocity, and pressure) were less than 2%. The mesh was then chosen for our simulations. The number of elements used for the 10 plaques is given in Table 2.
The FSI model with cyclic bending and boundary conditions
3D anisotropic and isotropic multi-component FSI models were constructed to calculate flow and stress/strain distributions and evaluate the effects of cyclic bending and anisotropic properties and demonstrations were given using the plaque sample shown in Figure 2. Blood flow was assumed to be laminar, Newtonian, and incompressible. The Navier-Stokes equations with arbitrary Lagrangian-Eulerian formulation were used as the governing equations. Cyclic bending was specified by prescribing periodic displacement at the lower edge of the vessel using data obtained from X-Ray angiography and keeping the total length of the vessel unchanged. No-slip conditions and natural traction equilibrium conditions are assumed at all interfaces. With that, we have:
where u and p are fluid velocity and pressure, u g is mesh velocity, μ is the dynamic viscosity (μ = 0.04 P), ρ is density, Γ stands for vessel inner boundary, x is the current position of Γ, σ is stress tensor (superscripts indicate different materials), ϵ is strain tensor, v is solid displacement vector, superscript letters “r” and “s” were used to indicate different materials. For simplicity, all material densities were set to 1 g⋅cm-3 in this paper.
3D coronary plaque FSI models for the ten patients were constructed and solved by ADINA (Adina R &D, Watertown, MA) to calculate flow and stress/strain distributions. Each IVUS slice was divided into 4 quarters with each quarter containing 25 data points taken on the lumen. Average FSS and PWS values from each quarter were obtained from all slices of a plaque corresponding to maximum pressure condition for statistical analysis. Standard linear correlation analysis was performed to find possible correlations between wall thickness and the mechanical stressess (FSS and PWS). Correlations with p < 0.05 were deemed significant.
Plaque wall thickness correlates positively with flow shear stress and negatively with plaque wall stress
Figures 6 & 7 and Table 3 give the correlation results between plaque (wall) thickness and flow shear stress (FSS) and plaque wall stress (PWS), respectively. Mean quarter values were used in the analysis. Corresponding to maximum pressure condition (for simplicity, this is also when maximum curvature occurs), nine out of the 10 patients showed positive correlation between plaque wall thickness and flow shear stress. The mean Pearson correlation r-value was 0.278 ± 0.181. Similarly, 9 out of the 10 patients showed negative correlation between wall thickness and plaque wall stress. The mean Pearson correlation r-value was -0.530 ± 0.210.
Corresponding to minimum pressure condition (this is also when minimum curvature occurs), 7 out of the 10 patients showed positive correlation between plaque wall thickness and flow shear stress, 1 showed negative correlation, 2 showed no significance. The mean Pearson correlation r-value was 0.272 ± 0.189. For plaque wall stress, 9 out of the 10 patients showed negative correlation between wall thickness and plaque wall stress, about the same as the maximum pressure case. The mean Pearson correlation r-value was -0.537 ± 0.238.
Effect of cyclic bending on plaque wall stress and strain behaviors
To demonstrate the effect of cyclic bending on plaque stress and strain behaviors, plaque wall stress (PWS) and strain (PWSn) from the baseline model of the plaque given in Figure 2 (Model 1-M1) and the model without cyclic bending (Model 2 – M2) are given in Figure 8. Model 2 used the minimum curvature from Model 1 and no cyclic bending was imposed. For simplicity, zero phase angle between pressure profile and curvature change was assumed, i.e., maximum and minimum bending in Model 1 occurred with maximum and minimum pressure conditions. Maximum PWS from M1 corresponding to maximum bending was about 100% higher than that corresponding to minimum bending (170.3 kPa vs. 84.51 kPa), while maximum PWS from M2 (no bending) corresponding to the maximum pressure condition was only 34% higher than that corresponding to minimum pressure condition (113.28 kPa vs. 84.49 kPa). Maximum PWS at maximum bending from M1 was about 50% higher than that from M1 at the same pressure condition. Differences in maximum of PWSn were similar to that of PWS. It should be noted that cyclic bending changed the stress/strain distribution patterns. The maximum bending caused some compression to the inner side of the vessel as shown by the lower PWS and PWSn regions in Figure 8a and e.
Effects of cyclic bending on flow behaviors
It is reasonable to expect that cyclic bending would have impact on flow behaviors. Flow velocity and flow shear stress from M1 and M2 are given in Figure 9. It is observed that flow velocity and flow shear stress from both M1 and M2 corresponding to maximum pressure condition were much higher than those corresponding to minimum pressure condition. That was caused by flow rate changes in the cardiac cycle. Cyclic bending did cause about 1% (or less) decreases in flow velocity and flow shear stress. The decreases were smaller than previously reported  because the curvature change is small between M1 and M2 while we compared a curved vessel with a nearly straight vessel.
Our results show that IVUS data could be used to construct computational models to calculate flow shear stress and plaque stress/strain conditions which may be used to identify possible mechanisms governing plaque progression and rupture. This adds mechanical stress conditions into the list of risk factors and represents a new direction of research. While many factors are involved in plaque progression and rupture process, it is natural to think that final plaque rupture happens when critical plaque stress/strain exceed the plaque cap ultimate material strength. IVUS-based computational models can provide accurate stress/strain calculations and can serve as a useful tool for physicians in their diagnosis and intervention surgical decision making process.
It should be made clear that our current data is wall thickness, which is not progression by itself. We are currently working on patient follow-up data and will report our findings when available. Plaque progression and rupture are closely related to each other. A better understanding of plaque progression may lead to better understanding of plaque rupture process and more accurate plaque assessment schemes.
Some limitations of this study include: a) patient-specific and tissue-specific material properties were not available for our study; b) while the angiographic movie provided information for the position of the myocardium and partial information for curvature variations, two movies with different (preferably orthogonal) view angles are needed to re-construct the 3D motion of the coronary and provide accurate curvature variation information; c) some data such as zero-stress conditions (opening angle), multi-layer vessel morphology and material properties are not possible to measure non-invasively in vivo; d) tethering and interaction between the heart and vessel could not be included because those measurements are not currently available. A model coupling heart motion and coronary bending would be desirable when required data become available.
Image-based computational models with cyclic bending and fluid-structure interactions could be used to provide more accurate flow and mechanical stress/strain calculations which may be useful for plaque assessment and identification of mechanisms governing plaque progression and rupture. Our results indicated that plaque wall thickness had positive correlation with flow shear stress and negative correlation with plaque wall stress. More patient follow-up data are needed to continue our investigations.
Tang’s group has been publishing image-based modeling work in recent years. For more information, please visit Tang’s website: http://users.wpi.edu/~dtang/.
The Washington University group (Jie Zheng and Richard Bach) has been publishing in medical imaging for vulnerable plaques extensively, see website:
Ma and Zhu are clinicians and have been doing research in interventional medicine for coronary diseases: http://www.njzdyy.com/s/21/t/2/00/d2/info210.htm;
The Columbia group (Cardiovascular Research Foundation, Mintz and Maehara) has been playing a leading role in the cardiovascular research. Web: http://www.crf.org/
Fleg JL, Stone GW, Fayad ZA, Granada JF, Hatsukami TS, Kolodgie FD, Ohayon J, Pettigrew R, Sabatine MS, Tearney GJ, Waxman S, Domanski MJ, Srinivas PR, Narula J: Detection of high-risk atherosclerotic plaque: report of the NHLBI working group on current status and future directions. JACC Cardio Imaging 2012,5(9):941–955. 10.1016/j.jcmg.2012.07.007
Ohayon J, Finet G, Gharib AM, Herzka DA, Tracqui P, Heroux J, Rioufol G, Kotys MS, Elagha A, Pettigrew RI: Necrotic core thickness and positive arterial remodeling index: emergent biomechanical factors for evaluating the risk of plaque rupture. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 2008, 295: H717-H727. 10.1152/ajpheart.00005.2008
Friedman MH, Krams R, Chandran KB: Flow interactions with cells and tissues: cardiovascular flows and fluid-structure interactions. Ann Biomed Eng 2010, 38: 1178–1187. 10.1007/s10439-010-9900-1
Fuster V: The vulnerable atherosclerotic plaque: understanding, identification, and modification. In AHA Monograph Series. Edited by: Valentin F, Cornhill JF, Dinsmore RE, Fallon JT, Insull W, Libby P, Nissen S, Rosenfeld ME, Wagner WD. Armonk NY: Futura Publishing; 1998.
Fuster V, Stein B, Ambrose JA, Badimon L, Badimon JJ, Chesebro JH: Atherosclerotic plaque rupture and thrombosis, evolving concept. Circulation 1990, 82: SII-47–59.
Tang D, Teng Z, Canton G, Yang C, Ferguson M, Huang X, Zheng J, Woodard PK, Yuan C: Sites of rupture in human atherosclerotic carotid plaques are associated with high structural stresses: an in vivo MRI-based 3D fluid-structure interaction study. Stroke 2009,40(10):3258–3263. Featured article on MDlinx.com 10.1161/STROKEAHA.109.558676
Friedman MH, Bargeron CB, Deters OJ, Hutchins GM, Mark FF: Correlation between wall shear and intimal thickness at a coronary artery branch. Atherosclerosis 1987, 68: 27–33. 10.1016/0021-9150(87)90090-6
Ku DN, Giddens DP, Zarins CK, Glagov S: Pulsatile flow and atherosclerosis in the human carotid bifurcation: positive correlation between plaque location and low and oscillating shear stress. Arteriosclerosis 1985, 5: 293–302. 10.1161/01.ATV.5.3.293
Samady H, Eshtehardi P, McDaniel MC, Suo J, Dhawan SS, Maynard C, Timmins LH, Quyyumi AA, Giddens DP: Coronary artery wall shear stress is associated with progression and transformation of atherosclerotic plaque and arterial remodeling in patients with coronary artery disease. Circulation 2011, 124: 779–788. 10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.111.021824
Stone PH, Saito S, Takahashi S, Makita Y, Nakamura S, Kawasaki T, Takahashi A, Katsuki T, Nakamura S, Namiki A, Hirohata A, Matsumura T, Yamazaki S, Yokoi H, Tanaka S, Otsuji S, Yoshimachi F, Honye J, Harwood D, Reitman M, Coskun AU, Papafaklis MI, Feldman CL, PREDICTION Investigators: Prediction of progression of coronary artery disease and clinical outcomes using vascular profiling of endothelial shear stress and arterial plaque characteristics: the PREDICTION Study. Circulation 2012,126(2):172–181. 10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.112.096438
Holzapfel GA, Stadler M, Schulze-Bause CAJ: A layer-specific three-dimensional model for the simulation of balloon angioplasty using. Magnetic Resonance Imaging and mechanical testing. Annals Biomed Eng 2002,30(6):753–767.
Virmani R, Kolodgie FD, Burke AP, Farb A, Schwartz SM: Lessons from sudden coronary death: a comprehensive morphological classification scheme for atherosclerotic lesions. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 2000,20(5):1262–1275. 10.1161/01.ATV.20.5.1262
Tang D, Yang C, Zheng J, Woodard PK, Sicard GA, Saffitz JE, Yuan C: 3D MRI-based multi-component FSI models for atherosclerotic plaques, a 3-D FSI model. Annals Biomed Eng 2004,32(7):947–960.
Tang D, Yang C, Zheng J, Woodard PK, Saffitz JE, Petruccelli JD, Sicard GA, Yuan C: Local maximal stress hypothesis and computational plaque vulnerability index for atherosclerotic plaque assessment. Ann Biomed Eng 2005,33(12):1789–1801. 10.1007/s10439-005-8267-1
Yang C, Canton G, Yuan C, Ferguson M, Hatsukami TS, Tang D: Advanced human carotid plaque progression correlates positively with flow shear stress: an in vivo MRI multi-patient 3D FSI study. J Biomech 2010,43(13):2530–2538. 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2010.05.018
Loree HM, Kamm RD, Stringfellow RG, Lee RT: Effects of fibrous cap thickness on peak circumferential stress in model atherosclerotic vessels. Circ Res 1992, 71: 850–858. 10.1161/01.RES.71.4.850
Cardoso L, Weinbaum S: Changing views of the biomechanics of vulnerable plaque rupture: a review. Ann Biomed Eng 2013. [Epub ahead of print]
Vengrenyuk Y, Carlier S, Xanthos S, Cardoso L, Ganatos P, Virmani R, Einav S, Gilchrist L, Weinbaum S: A hypothesis for vulnerable plaque rupture due to stress-induced debonding around cellular microcalcifications in thin fibrous caps. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2006,103(40):14678–14683. 10.1073/pnas.0606310103
Stary HC, Blankenhorn DH, Chandler AB, Glagov S, Insull W Jr, Richardson M, Rosenfeld ME, Schaffer SA, Schwartz CJ, Wagner WD, Wissler RW: A definition of the intima of human arteries and of its atherosclerosis-prone regions. A report from the Committee on Vascular Lesions of the Council on Arteriosclerosis, AHA. Circulation 1992, 85: 391–405. 10.1161/01.CIR.85.1.391
Stary HC, Chandler AB, Glagov S, Guyton JR, Insull W Jr, Rosenfeld ME, Schaffer SA, Schwartz CJ, Wagner WD, Wissler RW: A definition of initial, fatty streak and intermediate lesions of atherosclerosis. A report from the Committee on Vascular Lesions of the Council on Arteriosclerosis, AHA. Circulation 1994, 89: 2462–2478. 10.1161/01.CIR.89.5.2462
Stary HC, Chandler AB, Dinsmore RE, Fuster V, Glagov S, Insull W Jr, Rosenfeld ME, Schwartz CJ, Wagner WD, Wissler RW: A Definition of advanced types of atherosclerotic lesions and the histological classification of atherosclerosis. A report from the Committee on Vascular Lesions of the Council on Arteriosclerosis, AHA. Circulation 1995, 92: 1355–1374. 10.1161/01.CIR.92.5.1355
Tang D, Teng Z, Canton G, Hatsukami TS, Dong L, Huang X, Yuan C: Local critical stress correlates better than global maximum stress with plaque morphological features linked to atherosclerotic plaque vulnerability: an in vivo multi-patient study. Biomed Eng Online 2009, 8: 15. 10.1186/1475-925X-8-15
Yang C, Bach R, Zheng J, El Naqa I, Woodard PK, Teng ZZ, Billiar KL, Tang D: In vivo IVUS-based 3D fluid structure interaction models with cyclic bending and anisotropic vessel properties for human atherosclerotic coronary plaque mechanical analysis. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 2009,56(10):2420–2428.
Kural MH, Cai MC, Tang D, Gwyther T, Zheng J, Billiar KL: Planar biaxial characterization of diseased human coronary and carotid arteries for computational modeling. J Biomech 2012,45(5):790–798. 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2011.11.019
Holzapfel GA, Gasser TC, Ogden RW: A new constitutive framework for arterial wall mechanics and a comparative study of material models. J Elasticity 2000, 61: 1–48. 10.1023/A:1010835316564
Holzapfel GA, Sommer G, Regitnig P: Anisotropic mechanical properties of tissue components in human atherosclerotic plaques. J Biomech Eng 2004,126(5):657–665. 10.1115/1.1800557
Holzapfel GA, Mulvihill JJ, Cunnane EM, Walsh MT: Computational approaches for analyzing the mechanics of atherosclerotic plaques: a review. J Biomech 2014. in press
This research was supported by US NIH/NIBIB R01 EB004759. Yang's research was supported in part by National Sciences Foundation of China 11171030.
Other than the grants listed in the acknowledgement section, the authors declare that they have no other competing interest.
DT, JZ and GSM were responsible for the design, data collection and overall investigation. RF, CY and WL were responsible for computational modeling and statistical data analysis. KB was responsible for plaque material mechanical testing. JZ, DM, JZ, GM, AM and GSM were responsible for data collection and image analysis. All authors 1) have made substantial contributions to conception and design, or acquisition of data, or analysis and interpretation of data; 2) have been involved in drafting the manuscript or revising it critically for important intellectual content; and 3) have given final approval of the version to be published. Each author has participated sufficiently in the work to take public responsibility for appropriate portions of the content.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Fan, R., Tang, D., Yang, C. et al. Human coronary plaque wall thickness correlated positively with flow shear stress and negatively with plaque wall stress: an IVUS-based fluid-structure interaction multi-patient study. BioMed Eng OnLine 13, 32 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1186/1475-925X-13-32
- Fluid-structure interaction
- Plaque rupture
- Plaque progression