- Open Access
A color spectrographic phonocardiography (CSP) applied to the detection and characterization of heart murmurs: preliminary results
BioMedical Engineering OnLine volume 10, Article number: 42 (2011)
Although cardiac auscultation remains important to detect abnormal sounds and murmurs indicative of cardiac pathology, the application of electronic methods remains seldom used in everyday clinical practice. In this report we provide preliminary data showing how the phonocardiogram can be analyzed using color spectrographic techniques and discuss how such information may be of future value for noninvasive cardiac monitoring.
We digitally recorded the phonocardiogram using a high-speed USB interface and the program Gold Wave http://www.goldwave.com in 55 infants and adults with cardiac structural disease as well as from normal individuals and individuals with innocent murmurs. Color spectrographic analysis of the signal was performed using Spectrogram (Version 16) as a well as custom MATLAB code.
Our preliminary data is presented as a series of seven cases.
We expect the application of spectrographic techniques to phonocardiography to grow substantially as ongoing research demonstrates its utility in various clinical settings. Our evaluation of a simple, low-cost phonocardiographic recording and analysis system to assist in determining the characteristic features of heart murmurs shows promise in helping distinguish innocent systolic murmurs from pathological murmurs in children and is expected to useful in other clinical settings as well.
During the cardiac cycle, the normal heart produces repeatable physiological sounds. However, under some pathologic conditions, such as valvular disease or ventricular septal defects, the presence of turbulent blood flow leads to the production of additional sounds, called murmurs, which are random rather than deterministic in nature. Although the stethoscope has been used for almost two centuries, it is still frequently difficult to determine whether a heart murmur is abnormal or innocent murmur. Furthermore, detecting structural abnormities of the heart such as mitral stenosis or insufficiency remains an important clinical problem. Although many such abnormities can be detected by careful auscultation, generally only experienced cardiologists are able to detect important but subtle auscultatory findings with reliability [1–6]. Although echocardiography is frequently used to identify and characterize such abnormities, it is an expensive technology that is generally not suitable for either mass-screening or continuous monitoring. In addition, its operation requires a considerable knowledge and skill. Similar problems exist with cardiac catheterization methods.
The present study seeks to apply a relatively new technique, known herein as Color Spectrographic Phonocardiography (CSP), to develop a noninvasive instrument to assist in the detection and characterization of heart murmurs. The study builds on the work of others in the field of classical and digital phonocardiography. In particular, techniques such as time-frequency analysis of acoustic emissions, neural network methods, acoustic spectral averaging, and wavelet techniques have all been are used for the analysis of heart sounds and murmurs [7–18].
We collected the heart sounds at the pediatric clinic of Modares Hospital in Tehran between 2009 to 2010. The study was approved by the ethics committee of the hospital and the study protocol conforms to the ethical guidelines of the 1975 Declaration of Helsinki as reflected in a priori approval by the institution's human research committee. Data were collected from a total of 55 patients, including 5 normal cases, with an age range of 1 month to 14 years. Written informed consent was obtained from the patients for publication of the case reports and accompanying images. A copy of the written consent is available for review by the Editor-in-Chief of this journal. The patients and the normal ones had a history of heart murmur, which included 20 with a ventricular septal defect (VSD), 7 with an atrial septal defect (ASD), 4 with Tetralogy of Fallot (TOF), 10 with aortic stenosis (AS), 5 with pulmonary stenosis (PS), and 4 having mitral regurgitation (MR). In all cases, the diagnosis was confirmed by echocardiography. The summary of medical history and diagnostic findings for some samples can be seen in Table 1.
The data were recorded using a laptop computer-based phonocardiographic recording system developed at the Science and Research Branch of Islamic Azad University. Figure 1 shows the system used. A miniature electret microphone, connected to a precordial chest piece, was connected to a commercial audio amplifier whose output was then digitized at 44 KHz with 16 bits resolution. A similar arrangement was also used to record the electrocardiogram (ECG), which was recorded to assist in the identification of the start of each cardiac cycle. (Because the ECG was digitized using a sound card that was high-pass filtered at around 20 Hz, this signal was somewhat different than those recorded under full-bandwidth conditions. Despite this, however, the QRS complex of the ECG still could be used as a marker of the beginning of each cardiac cycle.) This setup was placed on a mobile cart for easy recording in cardiology clinics and elsewhere. Table 2 shows the equipment list which were used for recording the data.
Microphone calibration was performed using a Sound Level Calibrator, 94dB Model 407744 which produces a sinusoidal wave in 1 KHz and 94 dB SPL intensity. Comparing the recorded sound to the calibration recordings, it was then possible to obtain the absolute intensity measurements.
In order to achieve high-quality recordings, the recording environment was kept completely silent, with the patients lying in the supine position. Each recording was divided into five sections of 3 minutes each. Care was taken to ensure that borborygmi sounds (from stomach and intestines) and other artifacts were not present. The Figure 2 shows a schematic of the recording system (left) and one of the cases during recording (right).
All sounds were recorded using the Goldwave software (version 5.55), which includes tools for recording, playing, filtering, and analyzing sounds. Using this software, we also deleted any electrical utility frequency (50 Hz) from the ECG recordings. Next, we wrote code in the MATLAB software programming environment, based on the FFT function, which enabled us to display the phonocardiographic graphs in color spectrographic form. (Additional file 1: Appendix). It should be emphasized that the phonocardiographic graphs are presented in the time domain but the spectrograms are plots in both frequency and time. The color spectrograms let us calculate the required frequency in terms of the time using the colors intensity.
The Figure 3 shows sample phonocardiographic (middle) and electrocardiographic (top) recording obtained from a healthy six year old girl with an innocent murmur. The corresponding color spectrogram is shown in the bottom. The recording is of 5 cardiac cycles covering an elapsed time of 3.35 seconds. Note that the frequency of the murmur is largely under 200 Hz. Furthermore, S1 and S2 can be readily identified in the phonocardiogram signal.
The Figure 4 presents the data for a case of VSD in an 8 month old girl. Five cardiac cycles are shown. The spectrographic graph, bottom of the figure, indicates that the murmur has frequency components extending to 700 Hz. Noting to the graph, we found out the position of the murmur is between S1 and S2.
Five cardiac cycles of data for a 3 year old girl with an ASD are shown in Figure 5. The murmur has frequency components that extend to around 300 Hz. The second heart sound is clearly split in both the phonocardiogram and in the corresponding spectrogram.
The Figure 6 presents data for a 6 year old boy with AS. The recording covers 5 heart cycles and takes 5.40 seconds. The murmur is between S1 and S2 and extends to about 400 Hz.
Data for a 14 year old boy with PS are presented in Figure 7. This diamond-shaped systolic murmur has components to over 600 Hz. P2 could be heard.
Data for an 11 year old girl with TOF are presented in Figure 8, which shows a systolic murmur with frequency components extending to around 4 00 Hz.
The Figure 9 is from a 10 year old boy with MR. A systolic murmur with components extending to 400 Hz is evident.
Compared to pathological systolic murmurs, innocent systolic murmurs were found to have a lower peak frequency, below 200 Hz, have a shorter duration, and always faded in intensity before the second heart sound. In addition, the first and second heart sounds were readily discernible in innocent pediatric murmurs.
In all of the graphs, S1 has lower frequency than S2. We believe that the following explanation explains this finding. The elastic modulus (E) of the atria and ventricles are much less than for the arterial walls. It is known from vibration theory that a vibrating mechanical system with small elastic modulus oscillates with lower frequency than a system with higher elastic modulus. Therefore, a smaller elastic modulus results in a lower frequency of oscillation . Also, since the blood volume in the larger arteries is normally less than the blood in the ventricles this results in less inertia for the oscillating volume. Consequently, the frequency of the second heart sound (S2) tends to be higher than for the first heart sound (S1).
We found out each of the heart sounds take more than 0.1 second, S1:0.14 s and S2: 0.11s. Both of these sounds are low-frequency sounds but S1 more so than S2. Furthermore, the S2 duration was found to be less than that for S1, presumably in part because the attenuation of S2, from the arterial walls, is more rapid than for S1, from the ventricular walls.
Investigating the spectrogram of the VSD patient in Figure 4, we note that this was a holosystolic murmur. Note also that the shape of the VSD murmur in this case is rather similar to that in Additional file 2: Table S1. The murmur which is heard in ASD patients is mostly mid systolic in character and is caused from an increase in blood leaving the right ventricle. The increase of the load presented to the right ventricle makes the duration of the systole longer. This is associated with a splitting of S2, as noted in the color spectrogram shown in Figure 5 (see red circles). Aortic stenosis (AS) is associated with a harsh mid systolic murmur in aorta area. In the AS patient shown in Figure 6, we observed that the murmur starts after S1 and reaches to maximum in the middle, 350~400 Hz frequency, and shrinks to a minimum before S2. The shape of murmur here is also similar to that in Table S1. In Pulmonary Stenosis (PS), the blood is not able to easily enter into the pulmonary artery. This condition is characterized by a harsh systolic murmur, Figure 7, which is comparable to the shape shown in Additional. file 2: Table S1. In the case of TOF(VSD, right ventricular hypertrophy, PS, and overriding aorta)since VSD and PS are both have systolic murmurs, the result is a systolic murmur resulting from two sources, Figure 8. Finally, in the MR case, Figure 9, note the presence of a holosystolic murmur with an apparent early diastolic murmur (likely due to rapid antegrade flow through the mitral orifice).
Our eventual aim is to collect a sufficient number of cases to allow us to separately investigate the time-domain and spectrographic characteristics of each form of cardiac disease, so as to establish what characteristics each condition has in common that are not present in a collection of normal recordings. This would first require a careful examination of the two sets of data (pathologic and normal) to find candidate parameters that would help distinguish the two groups. This would likely be followed by formal pattern recognition methods to identify which parameters or set of parameters best separate the recording into "normal" and "abnormal" groups. In addition, we are exploring the possibility of developing "digital subtraction phonocardiography" methods that we hope will be able to separate any murmurs from underlying deterministic heart sounds. Our hope here is to develop an easily-implemented and inexpensive non-invasive approach to distinguish the murmurs from the underlying normal heart sounds by processing the acquired phonocardiogram and electrocardiogram of a patient. This approach will be developed and evaluated first by applying advanced signal processing techniques on mathematical simulations of signals containing both deterministic heart sounds and random (as in stochastic) murmurs. The information obtained from this preliminary analysis will be evaluated on healthy volunteers to determine the clinical factors that may affect the implementation of the new approach. Our hope is that the new technique will be evaluated in a cohort of patients with pathological murmurs to determine its clinical potential through a comparison of the results with those from classical auscultation and echocardiography on these patients.
Finally, some limitations of the present study should be emphasized. First, we expect that inexperienced clinical examiners need some guidance in the form of rules about how to read the spectrograms. Such rules have not yet been well researched. Another limitation is that the source of the continuous low frequency energy found in many recordings is not yet known; one possible cause we are considering is poor skin contact of the chest piece. Finally, studies on a large number of patients with homogeneous cardiac defects like VSDs will be necessary to make this technology more useful.
Recently, Noponen et al.  studied the phono-spectrographic features of heart murmurs to investigate how features obtained from a phono-spectrogram can be used to distinguish innocent murmurs from pathological murmurs in children. In another study, Kudriavtsev et al.  developed an approach based on spectrograms to present an intensity/frequency image of heart sound properties across time, which they called heart energy signature spectrogram. Our study extends this cardiac spectrographic experience for a number of cardiac conditions. In summary, we present a relatively new method, called color spectrographic phonocardiography, which is relatively simple, non invasive, and low in cost. It can be learned easily and interpretation of the results is potentially easier than the use of time-domain data alone. The method can also be used for prolonged continuous monitoring.
atrial septal defect
Color Spectrographic Phonocardiography
Universal Serial Bus
Tetralogy of Fallot
ventricular septal defect.
Lok CE, Morgan CD, Ranganathan N: The accuracy and interobserver agreement in detecting the "gallop sounds" by cardiac auscultation. Chest 1998, 114: 1283–1288. 10.1378/chest.114.5.1283
Mangione S, Nieman LZ: Cardiac auscultatory skills of internal medicine and family practice trainees: a comparison of diagnostic proficiency. JAMA 1977, 278: 717–722.
St Clair EW, Oddone EZ, Waugh RA, Corey GR, Feussner JR: C Assessing housestaff diagnostic skills using a cardiology patient simulator. ANN Intern Med 1992, 117: 751–756.
Jordan MD, Taylor CR, Nyhuis AW, et al.: Audibility of the fourth heart sound. Relationship to presence of disease and examiner experience. Arch Intern Med 1987, 147: 721–726. 10.1001/archinte.147.4.721
Ishmail AA, Wing S, Ferguson J, et al.: Interobserver agreement by auscultation in the presence of a third heart sound in patients with congestive heart failure. Chest 1987, 91: 870–873. 10.1378/chest.91.6.870
Prakash R, Aytan N, Dhingra R, et al.: Variability in the detection of a fourth heart sound-its clinical significance in elderly subjects. Cardiology 1974, 59: 49–56. 10.1159/000169663
Noponen AN, Lukkarinen S, Angerla A, Sepponen R: V Phono-spectrographic analysis of heart murmurs in children. BMC Pediatrics 2007, 7: 23. 10.1186/1471-2431-7-23
Kudriavtsev Vladimir, Polyshchuk Vladimir, Roy DouglasL: Heart energy signature spectrogram for cardiovascular diagnosis. Biomedical Engineering Online 2007, 6: 16. 10.1186/1475-925X-6-16
Rangayyan RM, Lehner R: Phonocardiogram Signal Analysis: A Review. B CRC Critical Reviews in Biomedical Engineering 1988, 15: 3.
Durand LG, Blanchard M, Cloutier G, Sabbah HN, Stein PD: P Comparison of pattern recognition methods for computer-assisted classification of spectra of heart sounds in patients with a porcine bioprosthetic valve implanted in the mitral position. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 1990, 37(12):1121–1129. 10.1109/10.64456
Khadra L, Matalgah M, El-Asir B, Mawagdeh S: The Wavelet transform and its applications to phonocardiogram signal analysis. Med Inform 1991., 271:
Bentley PM, McDonnell JTE: Analysis of heart sounds using the wavelet transform. Proc 16th Annual Int Conf IEEE Eng Med & Biol Soc 1994, 2: 1282.
Guo Z, Durand LG, Lee HC, Allard L, Grenier MC, Stein PD: Artificial neural networks in computer-assisted classification of heart sounds in patients with porcine bioprosthetic valves. PMed Biol Eng 1994, 32(3):311–316.
Durand LG, Pibarot P: A Digital Signal Processing of the Phonocardiogram: Review of the Most Recent Advancements. Critical Reviews in Biomedical Engineering 1995, 23(3/4):163–219.
Tranulis C, Durand LG, Senhadji L, Pibarot P: A Estimation of pulmonary arterial pressure by a neural network analysis using features based on time-frequency representations of the second heart sound. Med Biol Eng Comput 2002, 40(2):205–212. 10.1007/BF02348126
Kim D, Tavel ME: Assessment of severity of aortic stenosis through time-frequency analysis of murmur. Chest 2003, 124(2):728–731. 10.1378/chest.124.2.728
Tavel ME, Katz H: A Usefulness of a new sound spectral averaging technique to distinguish an innocent systolic murmur from that of aortic stenosis. American journal of cardiology 2005, 95: 728–731.
Tavel ME: A Cardiac auscultation: A glorious past but does it have future. American journal of cardiology 2005, 95: 728–731.
Thomson WilliamT, Marie Dillon Dahleh: A Theory of Vibration with Applications (5th Edition) (9780136510680). Prentice Hall 2002. ISBN:013651068
John Michael Criley: The Physiological Origins of Heart Sounds and Murmurs: The Unique Interactive Guide to Cardiac Diagnosis. Lippincott Williams Wilkins 1997. ISBN-13 9780781716208
The authors of this manuscript have certified that they comply with the Principles of Ethical Publishing in Biomedical Engineering Online journal
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
RRS and HT conducted the data sampling and wrote the MATLAB code required for converting the murmurs into signals. JDD and MN supervised the research and JDD revised the manuscript and offered the research proposal. KH wrote the manuscript and coordinated the research. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Sarbandi, R.R., Doyle, J.D., Navidbakhsh, M. et al. A color spectrographic phonocardiography (CSP) applied to the detection and characterization of heart murmurs: preliminary results. BioMed Eng OnLine 10, 42 (2011) doi:10.1186/1475-925X-10-42
- Aortic Stenosis
- Atrial Septal Defect
- Ventricular Septal Defect
- Ventricular Septal Defect
- Heart Sound