Table 4 Data extraction from gray literature
From: Effects of vaccine registration on disease prophylaxis: a systematic review
Study | Population | Intervention | Outcomes | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study year, country | Target group | Programming platform | Methodology | Features and benefits | Limitations | Publication/evaluation | Incorporation/impact |
[30] 2019, Africa | Nurses, doctors, parents and school administration staff | Electronic systems for storing immunizations | Review data storage profiles in BRICS. Evaluate the use of a common electronic platform for accessing the Manual—by three segments paramedics, health care team, and responsible parties | Reduces information errors. Bidirectional flow. Control of immunization rates | Not implemented, just a proposal with impact analysis | In BRICS, only two countries have mixed control over digital and physical data: Brazil and Russia | Not implemented. Perception maps of replacing the current paper vaccination card with electronic vaccination |
[24] 2019, Italy | A total of 21 articles with memory system and IIS | Immunization Information Systems (IIS) | Systematic review—benefits of using IIS as a tool to combat vaccination hesitancy | Automatic reminder/recall system, system interoperability, decision support system, website interface, and ability to capture adverse events after vaccination; groupings | The types of systems analyzed exclude apps | Assessment of use of systems of record | Not conducted. It concludes that there are insufficient studies to evaluate the effectiveness of IIS in addressing vaccine hesitancy |
[27] 2019, Brazil | Not aplicable | PROimuni App | They developed and evaluated a mobile application on child vaccination. Test 22 nurse judges, 9 judges from the field of information and communication technologies; 22 mothers evaluated aspects such as: objectives, appearance, structure, usability, efficiency and interactivity | The app consists of 20 screens with functions such as: Immunization card, Vaccine information, Immunization schedule, Geolocation, Frequently asked questions | Extension of use and robustness of synchronization with the state system | Tool potential for vaccine management with cell phone | Not suitable. Proposal with ease of use and usability |