Skip to main content

Table 1 Overview of included studies

From: Movement visualisation in virtual reality rehabilitation of the lower limb: a systematic review

Study

Movement Visualisation

Immersion

Robotic device

Motor function

Sample population

Sample size

Aiello [35]

Indirect MV: OF

Non

No

Gait

T: MS

C: –

T: 10

C: –

Cikajlo [36]

Indirect MV: OF

Non

No

Balance

T: Stroke

C: Stroke

T: 6

C: 22

Fung [37]

Indirect MV: OF

Semi

No

Gait

T: Stroke

C: –

T: 2

C: –

Fung [38]

Indirect MV: OF

Semi

No

Gait, Balance

T: Stroke

C: healthy

T: 9

C: 9

Kizony [39]

Indirect MV: OF

Semi

No

Gait

T: Stroke

C: healthy

T: 12

C: 10

Park [40]

Indirect MV: OF

Semi

No

Gait

T: PD

C: –

T: 3

C: –

Yang [41]

Indirect MV: OF

Semi/full

No

Gait

T: Stroke

C: Stroke

T: 11

C: 9

Yang [42]

Indirect MV: OF

Non

No

Balance

T: Stroke

C: Stroke

T: 7

C: 7

Bergmann [22]

Indirect MV: OF

Non/semi

Yes (Lokomat)

Gait

T: Stroke

C: –

T: 1

C: –

Walker [43]

Indirect MV: AOF

Non/semi

No

Gait

T: Stroke

C: –

T: 6

C: –

Lamontagne [31]

Indirect MV: AOF

Full

No

Gait

Crossover:

(T) Stroke,

(C) healthy

Crossover:

(T) 12,

(C) 12

Lamontagne [44]

Indirect MV: AOF

Full

No

Gait

Crossover:

(T) Stroke,

(C) healthy

Crossover:

(T) 10,

(C) 11

Slobounov [24]

Indirect MV: AOF

Semi

No

Balance

T: healthy → TBI (within)

C: healthy

T: 10

C: 45

Betker [45]

Abstract MV: 2D

Non

No

Balance

T: Ataxia, Stroke, TBI

C: –

T: 3

C: –

Geiger [46]

Abstract MV: 2D

Non

No

Balance

T: Stroke

C: Stroke

T: 7

C: 6

Gil-Gomez [47]

Abstract MV: 2D

Non/semi

No

Balance

T: Stroke, TBI, BCN

C: Stroke, TBI, BCN

T: 9

C: 8

Jobst [48]

Abstract MV: 2D

Non

No

Balance

T: Ataxia

C1: Ataxia

C2: healthy

T: 36

C1: 36

C2: 10

Mercier [49]

Abstract MV: 2D

Non

No

Gait

T: Stroke

C: –

T: 1

C: –

Forrester [50]

Abstract MV: 2D

Non

Yes (Anklebot)

Ankle

T: Stroke

C: –

T: 8

C: –

Cho [17]

Abstract MV: 3D

&

Avartar MV: Rough figure

Game

No

Balance

T: Stroke

C: Stroke

T: 11

C: 11

Deutsch [51]

Abstract MV: 3D

Non

Yes (Rutgers Ankle Rehabilitation System)

Ankle

Exp. 1 & 2:

T: Stroke

C: –

Exp.1: T: 1, C: –

Exp.2: T: 3, C: –

Deutsch [52]

Abstract MV: 3D

Non

Yes (Rutgers Ankle Rehabilitation System)

Ankle

T: Stroke

C: –

T: 6

C: –

Mirleman [53, 54]

Abstract MV: 3D

Non

Yes (Rutgers Ankle Rehabilitation System)

Ankle

T: Stroke

C: Stroke

T: 9

C: 9

Cattaneo [55]

Tracking MV

Non

No

Balance

T: MS

C: –

T: 9

C: –

Deng [56]

Tracking MV

Non

No

Ankle

T: Stroke

C: Stroke

T: 8

C: 8

Dunning [57]

Tracking MV

Non

No

Gait, Ankle

T: Stroke

C: –

 T: 1

C: –

Durfee [58]

Tracking MV

Non

No

Ankle

 T: Stroke

C: –

T: 20

C: –

McClanachan [59]

Avartar MV: Rough figure

Game

No

Gait, Balance

Crossover: Stroke, TBI

Crossover: 21

Brütsch [18]

Avatar MV: Realistic body

Non/semi

Yes (Lokomat)

Gait

Crossover:

(T) BS-CP, TBI, MMC, SLE,

(C) healthy

Crossover:

(T) 10,

(C) 14

Schuler [19]

Avatar MV: Realistic body

Non/semi

Yes (Lokomat)

Gait

Crossover:

(T) MS, CP, Hip dysplasia, Cerebral haemorrhage, Encephalopathy, Transverse myelitis,

(C) healthy

Crossover:

(T) 9,

(C) 8

Brütsch [60]

Avatar MV: Realistic body

Non/semi

Yes (Lokomat)

Gait

Crossover:

(T) MS, CP, Hip dysplasia, Cerebral haemorrhage, Encephalopathy, symptomatic SCI,

(C) healthy

Crossover:

(T) 10,

(C) 8

Baram [25]

AR MV

AR

No

Gait

T1: MS

T2: MS

T1: 10

T2: 11

Baram [61]

AR MV

AR

No

Gait

T: MS

C: healthy

T: 16

C: 12

Kim [62]

AR MV

AR

No

Gait, Balance

T: Stroke

C: Stroke

T: 12

C: 12

Palma [63]

AR MV

Game

No

Balance

T: TBI

C: TBI

T: 7?

C: 7?

Sveistrup [64]

AR MV

AR

No

Balance

T1: TBI

T2: TBI

C: TBI

?

Jaffe [65]

AR MV

AR

No

Gait

T: Stroke

C: Stroke

T: 10

C: 10

Thornton [66]

AR MV

AR

No

Balance

T: TBI

C: TBI

T: 15

C: 12

Griffin [20]

AR MV

AR

No

Gait

T: PD (within)

T: 26

Ferrarin [21]

AR MV

&

Combined MV: AR + Abstract (2D)

AR

No

Gait

T: PD (within)

C: healthy (within)

T: 3

C: 3

Walker [67]

No MV

Non

No

Balance

T: Stroke

C1: Stroke

C2: Stroke

T: 16

C1: 16

C2: 14

Banz [68]

No MV

Non

Yes (Lokomat)

Gait

Crossover: iSCI

Crossover: 12

  1. AR augmented reality, OF optical flow, AOF active optical flow, non non-immersive, semi semi-immersive, full full-immersive, game commercial game, Ankle ankle movement training, T treatment group, C control group, MS multiple sclerosis, (BS-)CP bilateral spastic cerebral palsy, TBI traumatic brain injury, BCN Benign cerebral neoplasm, (i) SCI (incomplete) spinal cord injury, PD Parkinson’s disease, MMC meningomyelocele, SLE systemic lupus erythematodes, healthy no neurological disorder