From: Movement visualisation in virtual reality rehabilitation of the lower limb: a systematic review
Study | Movement Visualisation | Immersion | Robotic device | Motor function | Sample population | Sample size |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Aiello [35] | Indirect MV: OF | Non | No | Gait | T: MS C: – | T: 10 C: – |
Cikajlo [36] | Indirect MV: OF | Non | No | Balance | T: Stroke C: Stroke | T: 6 C: 22 |
Fung [37] | Indirect MV: OF | Semi | No | Gait | T: Stroke C: – | T: 2 C: – |
Fung [38] | Indirect MV: OF | Semi | No | Gait, Balance | T: Stroke C: healthy | T: 9 C: 9 |
Kizony [39] | Indirect MV: OF | Semi | No | Gait | T: Stroke C: healthy | T: 12 C: 10 |
Park [40] | Indirect MV: OF | Semi | No | Gait | T: PD C: – | T: 3 C: – |
Yang [41] | Indirect MV: OF | Semi/full | No | Gait | T: Stroke C: Stroke | T: 11 C: 9 |
Yang [42] | Indirect MV: OF | Non | No | Balance | T: Stroke C: Stroke | T: 7 C: 7 |
Bergmann [22] | Indirect MV: OF | Non/semi | Yes (Lokomat) | Gait | T: Stroke C: – | T: 1 C: – |
Walker [43] | Indirect MV: AOF | Non/semi | No | Gait | T: Stroke C: – | T: 6 C: – |
Lamontagne [31] | Indirect MV: AOF | Full | No | Gait | Crossover: (T) Stroke, (C) healthy | Crossover: (T) 12, (C) 12 |
Lamontagne [44] | Indirect MV: AOF | Full | No | Gait | Crossover: (T) Stroke, (C) healthy | Crossover: (T) 10, (C) 11 |
Slobounov [24] | Indirect MV: AOF | Semi | No | Balance | T: healthy → TBI (within) C: healthy | T: 10 C: 45 |
Betker [45] | Abstract MV: 2D | Non | No | Balance | T: Ataxia, Stroke, TBI C: – | T: 3 C: – |
Geiger [46] | Abstract MV: 2D | Non | No | Balance | T: Stroke C: Stroke | T: 7 C: 6 |
Gil-Gomez [47] | Abstract MV: 2D | Non/semi | No | Balance | T: Stroke, TBI, BCN C: Stroke, TBI, BCN | T: 9 C: 8 |
Jobst [48] | Abstract MV: 2D | Non | No | Balance | T: Ataxia C1: Ataxia C2: healthy | T: 36 C1: 36 C2: 10 |
Mercier [49] | Abstract MV: 2D | Non | No | Gait | T: Stroke C: – | T: 1 C: – |
Forrester [50] | Abstract MV: 2D | Non | Yes (Anklebot) | Ankle | T: Stroke C: – | T: 8 C: – |
Cho [17] | Abstract MV: 3D & Avartar MV: Rough figure | Game | No | Balance | T: Stroke C: Stroke | T: 11 C: 11 |
Deutsch [51] | Abstract MV: 3D | Non | Yes (Rutgers Ankle Rehabilitation System) | Ankle | Exp. 1 & 2: T: Stroke C: – | Exp.1: T: 1, C: – Exp.2: T: 3, C: – |
Deutsch [52] | Abstract MV: 3D | Non | Yes (Rutgers Ankle Rehabilitation System) | Ankle | T: Stroke C: – | T: 6 C: – |
Abstract MV: 3D | Non | Yes (Rutgers Ankle Rehabilitation System) | Ankle | T: Stroke C: Stroke | T: 9 C: 9 | |
Cattaneo [55] | Tracking MV | Non | No | Balance | T: MS C: – | T: 9 C: – |
Deng [56] | Tracking MV | Non | No | Ankle | T: Stroke C: Stroke | T: 8 C: 8 |
Dunning [57] | Tracking MV | Non | No | Gait, Ankle | T: Stroke C: – |  T: 1 C: – |
Durfee [58] | Tracking MV | Non | No | Ankle |  T: Stroke C: – | T: 20 C: – |
McClanachan [59] | Avartar MV: Rough figure | Game | No | Gait, Balance | Crossover: Stroke, TBI | Crossover: 21 |
Brütsch [18] | Avatar MV: Realistic body | Non/semi | Yes (Lokomat) | Gait | Crossover: (T) BS-CP, TBI, MMC, SLE, (C) healthy | Crossover: (T) 10, (C) 14 |
Schuler [19] | Avatar MV: Realistic body | Non/semi | Yes (Lokomat) | Gait | Crossover: (T) MS, CP, Hip dysplasia, Cerebral haemorrhage, Encephalopathy, Transverse myelitis, (C) healthy | Crossover: (T) 9, (C) 8 |
Brütsch [60] | Avatar MV: Realistic body | Non/semi | Yes (Lokomat) | Gait | Crossover: (T) MS, CP, Hip dysplasia, Cerebral haemorrhage, Encephalopathy, symptomatic SCI, (C) healthy | Crossover: (T) 10, (C) 8 |
Baram [25] | AR MV | AR | No | Gait | T1: MS T2: MS | T1: 10 T2: 11 |
Baram [61] | AR MV | AR | No | Gait | T: MS C: healthy | T: 16 C: 12 |
Kim [62] | AR MV | AR | No | Gait, Balance | T: Stroke C: Stroke | T: 12 C: 12 |
Palma [63] | AR MV | Game | No | Balance | T: TBI C: TBI | T: 7? C: 7? |
Sveistrup [64] | AR MV | AR | No | Balance | T1: TBI T2: TBI C: TBI | ? |
Jaffe [65] | AR MV | AR | No | Gait | T: Stroke C: Stroke | T: 10 C: 10 |
Thornton [66] | AR MV | AR | No | Balance | T: TBI C: TBI | T: 15 C: 12 |
Griffin [20] | AR MV | AR | No | Gait | T: PD (within) | T: 26 |
Ferrarin [21] | AR MV & Combined MV: ARÂ +Â Abstract (2D) | AR | No | Gait | T: PD (within) C: healthy (within) | T: 3 C: 3 |
Walker [67] | No MV | Non | No | Balance | T: Stroke C1: Stroke C2: Stroke | T: 16 C1: 16 C2: 14 |
Banz [68] | No MV | Non | Yes (Lokomat) | Gait | Crossover: iSCI | Crossover: 12 |