Skip to main content

Table 2 Literature review of parameters for RBC simulations using coarse-grained particle method applied in flows, normalised against particle number

From: Investigation of red blood cell mechanical properties using AFM indentation and coarse-grained particle method

2D paper Case N (particles) r (µm) \(k_{l,base}\) (N/m/particle) \(k_{b,base}\) (J/rad/particle) \(k_{a}\) (J)
Tsubota et al. [38] 76 3.0 1.1E+04 6.6E−12 1.0E−05
Wang et al. [40] Min 76 2.8 2.5E−02 1.3E−15 1.0E−09
Max 2.5E−01 1.3E−14 1.0E−08
Pan et al. [56] Min 76 2.8 2.5E−03 1.3E−16 1.0E−10
Max 7.4E−01 3.9E−14 3.0E−08
Shi et al. [22] 76 2.8 1.2E+04 6.6E−12 1.0E−05
Wang et al. [57] Min 76 2.8 2.5E−04 1.3E−17 1.0E−11
Max 1.2E−02 6.6E−16 5.0E−10
Tsubota et al. [41] Min 48 3.0 2.7E+01 4.2E−13 2.0E−07
Max 2.7E+03 4.2E−11 2.0E−05
Shi et al. [36] 76 2.8 1.2E+04 6.6E−12 1.0E−05
Polwaththe-Gallage et al. [33, 58] 88 2.8 1.4E+04 5.7E−12 1.0E−05
Polwaththe-Gallage et al. [34] 88 2.8 8.5E−01 3.4E−14 3.0E−08
Wang et al. [55] Min 76 2.8 7.4E−02 3.9E−15 3.0E−09
Max 7.4E−01 3.9E−14 3.0E−08
Present study 400 3.0 7.8E−04 9.8E−20 2.3E−10
3D paper Case N (particles) r (µm) \(k_{L,base}\) (N/m/particle) \(k_{B,base}\) (J/rad/particle) \(k_{V}\) (J)
Tsubota et al. [43] 2304 3.27 2.6E+04 5.6E−22 1.8E−16
Nakamura et al. [45] Not stated 3.25 Variable stiffness Not calculable 4.3E−15
Shi et al. [42] Min 770 3.28 7.1E−09 2.9E−21 4.7E−15
Max 9.7E−09 4.1E−21 4.7E−15
Wu et al. [48] 1 440 2.8 2.7E−08 3.2E−21 Not stated
2 1058 1.1E−08 1.3E−21 Not stated
Nakamura et al. [47]   2648 3.27 Variable stiffness 3.8E−06 4.4E−15
Polwaththe-Gallage et al. [35, 46] 954 3.1 1.6E−08 2.0E−20 3.7E−15
Present study 1922 3.3 1.1E−07 2.8E−18 7.0E−10