Investigation of red blood cell mechanical properties using AFM indentation and coarse-grained particle method

Table 2 Literature review of parameters for RBC simulations using coarse-grained particle method applied in flows, normalised against particle number

2D paper	Case	N (particles)	r (µm)	\(k_{l,base}\) (N/m/particle)	\(k_{b,base}\) (J/rad/particle)	\(k_{a}\) (J)
Tsubota et al. [38]	–	76	3.0	1.1E+04	6.6E−12	1.0E−05
Wang et al. [40]	Min	76	2.8	2.5E−02	1.3E−15	1.0E−09
Wang et al. [40]	Max	76	2.8	2.5E−01	1.3E−14	1.0E−08
Pan et al. [56]	Min	76	2.8	2.5E−03	1.3E−16	1.0E−10
Pan et al. [56]	Max	76	2.8	7.4E−01	3.9E−14	3.0E−08
Shi et al. [22]	–	76	2.8	1.2E+04	6.6E−12	1.0E−05
Wang et al. [57]	Min	76	2.8	2.5E−04	1.3E−17	1.0E−11
Wang et al. [57]	Max	76	2.8	1.2E−02	6.6E−16	5.0E−10
Tsubota et al. [41]	Min	48	3.0	2.7E+01	4.2E−13	2.0E−07
Tsubota et al. [41]	Max	48	3.0	2.7E+03	4.2E−11	2.0E−05
Shi et al. [36]	–	76	2.8	1.2E+04	6.6E−12	1.0E−05
Polwaththe-Gallage et al. [33, 58]	–	88	2.8	1.4E+04	5.7E−12	1.0E−05
Polwaththe-Gallage et al. [34]	–	88	2.8	8.5E−01	3.4E−14	3.0E−08
Wang et al. [55]	Min	76	2.8	7.4E−02	3.9E−15	3.0E−09
Wang et al. [55]	Max	76	2.8	7.4E−01	3.9E−14	3.0E−08
Present study	–	400	3.0	7.8E−04	9.8E−20	2.3E−10

3D paper	Case	N (particles)	r (µm)	\(k_{L,base}\) (N/m/particle)	\(k_{B,base}\) (J/rad/particle)	\(k_{V}\) (J)
Tsubota et al. [43]	–	2304	3.27	2.6E+04	5.6E−22	1.8E−16
Nakamura et al. [45]	–	Not stated	3.25	Variable stiffness	Not calculable	4.3E−15
Shi et al. [42]	Min	770	3.28	7.1E−09	2.9E−21	4.7E−15
Shi et al. [42]	Max	770	3.28	9.7E−09	4.1E−21	4.7E−15
Wu et al. [48]	1	440	2.8	2.7E−08	3.2E−21	Not stated
Wu et al. [48]	2	1058	2.8	1.1E−08	1.3E−21	Not stated
Nakamura et al. [47]		2648	3.27	Variable stiffness	3.8E−06	4.4E−15
Polwaththe-Gallage et al. [35, 46]	–	954	3.1	1.6E−08	2.0E−20	3.7E−15
Present study	–	1922	3.3	1.1E−07	2.8E−18	7.0E−10

ISSN: 1475-925X