Skip to main content

Table 2 Literature review of parameters for RBC simulations using coarse-grained particle method applied in flows, normalised against particle number

From: Investigation of red blood cell mechanical properties using AFM indentation and coarse-grained particle method

2D paper

Case

N (particles)

r (µm)

\(k_{l,base}\) (N/m/particle)

\(k_{b,base}\) (J/rad/particle)

\(k_{a}\) (J)

Tsubota et al. [38]

76

3.0

1.1E+04

6.6E−12

1.0E−05

Wang et al. [40]

Min

76

2.8

2.5E−02

1.3E−15

1.0E−09

Max

2.5E−01

1.3E−14

1.0E−08

Pan et al. [56]

Min

76

2.8

2.5E−03

1.3E−16

1.0E−10

Max

7.4E−01

3.9E−14

3.0E−08

Shi et al. [22]

76

2.8

1.2E+04

6.6E−12

1.0E−05

Wang et al. [57]

Min

76

2.8

2.5E−04

1.3E−17

1.0E−11

Max

1.2E−02

6.6E−16

5.0E−10

Tsubota et al. [41]

Min

48

3.0

2.7E+01

4.2E−13

2.0E−07

Max

2.7E+03

4.2E−11

2.0E−05

Shi et al. [36]

76

2.8

1.2E+04

6.6E−12

1.0E−05

Polwaththe-Gallage et al. [33, 58]

88

2.8

1.4E+04

5.7E−12

1.0E−05

Polwaththe-Gallage et al. [34]

88

2.8

8.5E−01

3.4E−14

3.0E−08

Wang et al. [55]

Min

76

2.8

7.4E−02

3.9E−15

3.0E−09

Max

7.4E−01

3.9E−14

3.0E−08

Present study

400

3.0

7.8E−04

9.8E−20

2.3E−10

3D paper

Case

N (particles)

r (µm)

\(k_{L,base}\) (N/m/particle)

\(k_{B,base}\) (J/rad/particle)

\(k_{V}\) (J)

Tsubota et al. [43]

2304

3.27

2.6E+04

5.6E−22

1.8E−16

Nakamura et al. [45]

Not stated

3.25

Variable stiffness

Not calculable

4.3E−15

Shi et al. [42]

Min

770

3.28

7.1E−09

2.9E−21

4.7E−15

Max

9.7E−09

4.1E−21

4.7E−15

Wu et al. [48]

1

440

2.8

2.7E−08

3.2E−21

Not stated

2

1058

1.1E−08

1.3E−21

Not stated

Nakamura et al. [47]

 

2648

3.27

Variable stiffness

3.8E−06

4.4E−15

Polwaththe-Gallage et al. [35, 46]

954

3.1

1.6E−08

2.0E−20

3.7E−15

Present study

1922

3.3

1.1E−07

2.8E−18

7.0E−10