Methods | Year | Sensitivity | FP | N ° of nodules | Size | Response time | Type of nodules |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Xu et al. [70] | 1997 | 70% | 1,7 per image | 122 | 4 - 27mm | 20s | NI |
Armato et al. [48] | 1999 | 70% | 9,6 per case | 187 | 3,1 - 27,8mm | NI | Solitary and juxtapleural |
Lee et al. [45] | 2001 | 72% | 25,3 per case | 98 | < 10mm | 187 min | NI |
Suzuki et al. [71] | 2003 | 80,3% | 4,8 per case | 121 | 4 - 27mm | 1,4s | Juxtavascular, hilum, ground-glass opacity andjuxtapleural |
Murphy et al. [40] | 2007 | 84% | 8,2 per case | 268 | 2 - 14mm | NI | Pleural and non-pleural |
Ye et al. [23] | 2009 | 90,2% | 8,2 per case | 220 | 2 - 20mm | 2,5 min | Juxtavascular, isolated, ground-glass opacityand juxtapleural |
Messay, Hardie and Rogers [21] | 2010 | 82,66% | 3 per case | 143 | 3 - 30mm | 2,3 min | Juxtavascular, solitary, ground-glass opacityand juxtapleural |
Liu et al. [20] | 2010 | 97% | 4,3 per case | 32 | NI | NI | Solitary |
Kumar et al. [75] | 2011 | 86% | 2,17 per case | 538 | NI | NI | NI |
Tan et al. [76] | 2011 | 87,5% | 4 per case | 574 | 3 - 30mm | NI | Isolated, juxtavascular, and juxtapleural |
Hong, Li and Yang [22] | 2012 | 89,47% | 11,9 per case | 44 | NI | NI | Solitary |
Cascio et al. [65] | 2012 | 97% | 6,1 per case | 148 | ≥ 3mm | 1,5 min | Internal and juxtapleural |
Orozco et al. [63] | 2012 | 96,15% | 2 per case | 50 | NI | NI | NI |
Teramoto and Fujita [24] | 2013 | 80% | 4,2 per case | 103 | 5 - 20mm | 30s | Juxtavascular, isolated, ground-glass opacityand juxtapleural |